We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile:
Sign in
or
Create
See all online law products
More
About
Subscriber Services
Guided Tour
FAQs
Help
Contact Us
Search
Browse all
Content type
Case reports
International court decisions
Domestic court decisions
European court cases
Arbitral cases
Commentary and analysis
Book content
Encyclopedia entries
Notes
International instruments and materials
Treaties
Supporting instruments
Institutional rules
Resolutions
Declarations
Model laws
Subject
Air law and law of outer space
Diplomacy and consular relations
History of international law
Human rights
Immunities
Individuals and non-state actors
International co-operation
International criminal law
International economic law
International environmental law
International humanitarian law
International law and international relations
International organizations
International procedural law
International responsibility
Law of the sea
Law of treaties
Relationship between international and domestic law
Settlement of disputes
Sources, foundations and principles of international law
Statehood, jurisdiction of states, organs of states
Territory
Theory of international law
Use of force, war, peace and neutrality
Author
Geographic region
Geographic Regions
Africa
Americas
Asia
Europe
Oceania
Organization
Organizations/Institutions
American Organizations/Institutions
African Organizations/Institutions
Asian Organizations/Institutions
European Organizations/Institutions
International Organizations/Institutions
Middle Eastern Organizations/Institutions
Pacific Rim Organizations/Institutions
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share Link
Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend
Email this content
or copy the link directly:
https://opil.ouplaw.com/view/10.1093/law/9780190900861.001.0001/law-9780190900861-partFrontMatter-21
Link copied successfully
The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
Copy link
Share This
Subscriber sign in
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgotten your password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Contents
Acknowledgments
Main Text
1 Introduction—Doctrine, Practice, and Advocacy in the Inter-American Human Rights System
A Balance of Jurisprudence and Practical Analysis
Organization of the Book
Part I: Introduction, Evolution and Operation of the Inter-American System
Part II: The Doctrine and Practice of the Inter-American System
Part III: Beyond Judgment—Reparations, Compliance, and the Future of the Inter-American System
Concluding Notes
Part One Introduction, Evolution, and Operation of the Inter-American System
Preliminary Material
2 Evolution of the System: The Inter-American Commission and Court
1 Introduction
2 Human Rights and the Organization of American States
3 The Creation of an Inter-American Normative Framework for the Protection of Human Rights in the Americas
3.1 The Development of the Convention
3.2 The Baby Boy Case as a Window into the Drafting Process of the Convention
4 The Structure and Evolution of the Commission and Court
4.1 Introduction
4.2 The First Years of Operation of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights: In Loco Visits and Country Reports
4.3 The First Years of Operation of the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights: Political Context and Tactical Choices
4.4 Commissioners’ Independence and Impartiality
4.5 Functions of the Commission
4.6 The Commission’s Country Reports in Historical Context
4.6.1 Some procedural and historical notes to keep in mind:
4.7 The Composition and Functions of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
4.8 The Early Years of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
5 Overview of the Case System
5.1 A Two-Tier System
5.2 The Evolution of Litigation in the System
6 The System’s Relations with the OAS Political Bodies and Member States
6.1 The System’s Relations with Other OAS Bodies
6.2 The System’s Relations with OAS Member States
6.3 The System’s Relations with the United States
3 Petitioning the Inter-American System: Admissibility Requirements for Contentious Cases
1 Introduction
2 Preliminary Objections: An Initial Overview
3 Jurisdictional Requirements
3.1 Jurisdiction Ratione Personae
3.1.1 Jurisdiction Ratione Personae in Inter-State Complaints
3.1.2 Standing to File a Petition
3.1.3 Standing to Submit a Case to the Court
3.1.4 Standing to File a Petition versus Identity of the Victims: Two Aspects of Active Competence
3.1.5 Jurisdiction Ratione Personae Regarding Legal Entities: Can Corporations Submit a Complaint to the Inter-American Commission?
3.2 Jurisdiction Ratione Materiae
3.3 Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis
3.3.1 Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis and the Nature of the Violations
3.3.2 Issues of Ratione Temporis: The Presumption of Death of a Disappeared Person for Purposes of Jurisdiction
3.3.3 The “Autonomous Violations” or “Independent Facts” Doctrine in Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis Inquiries
3.4 Jurisdiction Ratione Loci
4 Admissibility Requirements
4.1 The Rule of Exhaustion of Domestic Remedies
4.1.1 Unreasonable Delay: The Third Exception to the Exhaustion Requirement
4.1.2 The Relationship between the Rule of Exhaustion of Domestic Remedies and the Right to Judicial Protection (Article 25 of the Convention)
4.1.3 The Case of Brewer Carías v. Venezuela: Exception or New Trend?
4.2 The Six-Month Rule
4.3 Non-duplication of Procedures
4.4 The Fourth Instance Doctrine
4 Jurisdiction beyond Contentious Cases: What Else Can the System Do?
1 Introduction
2 Responding to Imminent Threats against Human Rights: Precautionary and Provisional Measures
2.1 Normative Framework
2.1.1 Comparative Note
2.2 Beneficiaries and Scope of Orders
2.3 Rights Protected by Precautionary Measures
2.4 Requirements and Proceedings to Request Precautionary Measures
2.5 Monitoring and Modification of Measures
3 Current Nonjudicial Activities of the Inter-American Commission
3.1 On-site Visits and Country Reports
3.2 Chapter IV of the Inter-American Commission Annual Report
3.3 Rapporteurships and Thematic Reports
3.4 Technical Cooperation Provided by the Commission to OAS Member States
3.5 CASE STUDY. Ayotzinapa: Civil Society Uses the Inter-American System to Push for Reform, Oversight, and Information
4 Advisory Jurisdiction and Opinions
Concluding Questions
Part Two The Doctrine and Practice of the Inter-American System
Preliminary Material
5 Mass Atrocity, Contemporary Responses, and Transitional Justice
A Historical Context
1 Introduction: Latin America from the Cuban Revolution to Democratic Transition
2 The Gradual Transition
3 Argentina’s “Dirty War”
3.1 The Military Dictatorship’s Human Rights Crimes
3.2 The Inter-American Commission Visits Argentina
3.3 Impact of the Commission’s Report and the End of the Dictatorship
B The Development of a Jurisprudence for Accountability and Victims’ Rights
4 Demanding Accountability for Crimes of the Dirty War
4.1 National Responses to Crimes of the Past: Truth Commissions in Argentina and Beyond
4.2 Criminal Prosecutions: The Trial of the Argentine Juntas
5 Truth but Not Justice? The Problem of the Amnesty Laws
5.1 Civil Society Challenges Amnesties: The Argentinean Process before the Inter-American System
5.2 The Commission and Uruguay’s Amnesty Law
5.3 The “Scilingo” Effect
5.4 The Inter-American Court Declares That Amnesty Laws for Grave Human Rights Violations Are without Legal Effect.
5.5 The International Context
5.6 The Barrios Altos Case
5.6.1 Internal Armed Conflict: Applications of Barrios Altos and International Law in the Face of a “Peace versus Justice” Debate
5.7 The Impact of Barrios Altos: Argentina
6 Crimes against Humanity and the Duty to Extradite
6.1 Amnesty and Chile: The Almonacid Case at the Inter-American Court
6.2 Paraguay: The Goiburú Case
C The System’s Impact and its Challenges in the Protection of the Rights of Victims of Mass Atrocity.
7 Analyzing the Impact of the Inter-American System
7.1 Incorporation of the System’s Amnesty Law Jurisprudence by Other Courts
8 Current Challenges in Transitional Justice and Accountability: Uneven Results and Continuing Impunity in the Americas
8.1 Behind the Curve: Impunity for Mexico’s Dirty War and Brazil’s Military Regime Abuses
8.1.1 Mexico
8.1.2 Brazil
9 Concluding Questions
6 The Right to Life
1 Introduction
2 The Right to Life and State Obligations in the Inter-American System: The Velásquez-Rodríguez Case
2.1 Background
2.1.1 Enforced Disappearances: A Brief History of a Tool of Repression
2.1.2 Background to Velásquez-Rodríguez: The Situation in Honduras
2.2 The Court’s Definition of Enforced Disappearances and the Rights It Violates
2.3 State Responsibility for Violations of the Right to Life even when the Responsible Party May Not Be a State Agent
2.4 Evidentiary Standards to Prove Human Rights Violations in the Context of State Failure to Investigate
3 Extrajudicial Killings by State Agents: The Court Clarifies Its Standards as States Finesse Their Defenses
3.1 Jurisdiction Ratione Temporis
3.2 Evidence Required for a Finding That the Victim Was in the Custody of State Agents.
3.3 Death in State Custody: Evidence Required to Prove State Responsibility.
3.4 Killings Resulting from State Agents’ Use of Force:
4 Expansion of Right to Life
4.1 Pueblo Bello v. Colombia: Duty to Prevent Reasonably Foreseeable Harm
4.2 States’ Heightened Duties Regarding the Protection of Children’s Human Rights
4.3 Duty to Ensure Conditions for a Dignified Life
4.4 Ximenes Lopes v. Brazil: Duty to Oversee Health Institutions to Ensure Appropriate Treatment of Patients
5 The Right to Life and the Application of the Death Penalty in the Americas
5.1 Prohibition on Executing Juveniles
5.2 Prohibitions on Backsliding, Reclassifying Non-death Penalty Crimes to Capital Crimes, and Other Limitations on the Death Penalty
5.3 Prohibition on Mandatory Application of the Death Penalty in Murder Cases
6 Abortion in the Inter-American System
6.1 Baby Boy v. United States
6.2 Artavia Murillo v. Costa Rica
C.2) Systematic and historical interpretation
C.2.a) Inter-American human rights system
iii) Systematic interpretation of the American Convention and the American Declaration
C.2.b) Universal human right system
i) Universal Declaration of Human Rights
ii) International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
iii) Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women
iv) Convention on the Rights of the Child
C.2.c) European human rights system
C.2.d) African human rights system
C.2.e) Conclusion concerning systematic interpretation
C.3) Evolutive interpretation
C.3.a) The legal status of the embryo
C.4) The principle of the most favorable interpretation, and the object and purpose of the treaty
C.5) Conclusion on the interpretation of Article 4(1)
7 Emergency, Armed Conflict, and Human Rights Protections in the Inter-American System
1 Introduction
2 Emergency Situations and Non-derogable Rights in the Inter-American System
2.1 Emergency Situations Viewed from Both Sides of the Atlantic
3 Persistent Protections to the Right to Life and State Obligations even during Times of Armed Conflict
3.1 Defining an Armed Conflict and Distinguishing It from Other Forms of Conflict and Political Disturbances
4 Applicable Standards and Obligations during Internal Armed Conflicts
B.3 The presumed machine gun attack
B.7 Conclusions
8 Detention and Conditions in Detention Centers
1 Introduction
2 The Initial Arrest and Detention
2.1 Article 7: The Right to Personal Liberty
2.2 Articles 8 (Right to a Fair Trial), 25 (Right to Judicial Protection)
3 Pretrial Detention
4 Connecting the Dots: Pacheco Teruel and Tragedy in Detention Centers
5 Prison Conditions and Atrocities: Peering into the Abyss
Venezuela
Chile
Mexico and Central America
5.1 The Universality of Abusive Prisons: The Commission’s Country Reports as a Barometer
6 Inter-American Standards on Conditions of Detention and Treatment of Prisoners: The Duty to Avoid Excessive Use of Force in Repressing Prison Riots
6.1 The Case of Neira Alegría v. Peru
6.2 The Case of the Detention Center of Catia
7 Detention, Mental Health, and Psychiatric Hospitals
7.1 Case Study: Rikers Island
8 Minimum Standards on Treatment of Prisoners: Incorporation of UN Standard Minimum Rules
8.1 Case Study: Urso Branco Prison
9 Best Practices Regarding Persons Deprived of Liberty
9.1 Defending the Rights of Those in Detention
10 Responding to Prison Violence: Provisional Measures for Prison Populations
10.1 Mendoza, Argentina Prisons
10.2 Provisional Measures in Venezuelan Prisons
11 Women in Detention: The System Develops a Gender Perspective
12 Immigration Detention
9 The Rights to Physical Integrity, Freedom from Torture, and Freedom from Third-Party Violence
1 Introduction
2 Normative Framework
3 Jurisdiction to Consider Claims of Violations of the Inter-American Convention to Prevent and Punish Torture
4 The Meaning of Torture and Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CIDT) under the American Convention and the Inter-American Convention to Prevent and Punish Torture
4.1 The Early Years
4.2 The Court Defines the Elements of Torture
4.3 Psychological Harm and Article 5 Protections
5 Evidence Required to Prove Torture under Inter-American Jurisprudence
6 The Obligation to Investigate Allegations of Torture
6.1 Jurisdiction Rationae Temporae over Violations of the Obligation to Investigate Acts of Torture When There Is Not Jurisdiction Rationae Temporae over Torture
7 Violations beyond the Direct Victim: Violations of the Right to Humane Treatment of Family Members of Victims of Serious Human Rights Violations
8 Conclusion
10 Women’s Rights, Gender, and Sexuality
1 Introduction
2 The Inter-American Convention on the Prevention, Punishment, and Eradication of Violence Against Women (the “Belém do Pará Convention”)
2.1 Belém do Pará: A Comparison With Regional and International Counterparts
2.2 The Belém do Pará Convention: Anatomy
2.3 The Belém do Pará Convention and the Court’s Jurisdiction
3 VAW and the Jurisprudence of the Inter-American System
3.1 A Brief Historical Overview of the Commission’s and the Court’s Consideration of Women’s Rights, Gender, and Sexuality
3.2 State-Sponsored Acts of Gendered Violence
3.2.1 The Court’s Initial Failures Regarding Issues of Gendered Violations: Loayza Tamayo and Caballero Delgado and Santana
3.2.2 Gender Enters the Picture: Plan de Sánchez Massacre and Castro-Castro v. Peru
3.2.3 The Commission Addresses Sexual Violence in Haiti as an Instrument of Political Violence and Terror
3.3 Private Acts of Gendered Violence
3.3.1 Domestic Violence and State Obligations: Maria da Penha v. Brazil
3.3.2 In re Cotton Field (IACtHR 2009)
3.3.3 Jessica Lenahan (Gonzales) v. United States (IACHR 2011)
4 New Lines of Inquiry: Sexuality and Reproductive Rights
4.1 The Rights of LGBTI Persons
4.2 In Vitro Fertilization: The Case of Artavia Murillo
4.3 Reproductive Rights and Precautionary Measures
5 Additional Mechanisms in the Inter-American System to Address the Rights of Women and LGBTI Persons
5.1 Rapporteurships on Women’s Rights and the Rights of LGBTI Persons
5.2 The Inter-American Commission on Women (CIM) and the Mechanism to Follow Up on Implementation of the Convention (MESECVI)
11 The Rights of Children
1 Who Is a Child in the Inter-American System?
2 The Normative Framework of Children’s Rights in the Inter-American System
3 The Evolution of the Protection of Children’s Rights in the Inter-American System
4 The Best Interests of the Child and the Special Measures to Protect Children’s Rights
5 The Applicability of These Principles to a Concrete Situation: The Case of Violence against Children
5.1 Human Mobility, Children’s Rights, and Complex Forms of Violence
6 Children and Their Right to Receive Protection from Their Family, to Have Their Family Protected and to Receive Protection for Family Life
7 Litigation of Children’s Rights in the Inter-American System
8 Children’s Rights and the Interaction with Domestic Legal Systems
12 Indigenous and Tribal Peoples’ Rights and the Inter-American System
1 Introduction
2 Who Are Indigenous and Tribal Peoples?
3 The Applicability of Human Rights Law to Indigenous Rights
4 The Duty to Adopt Special Measures to Protect Indigenous Peoples:
5 Violence against Indigenous Peoples and Its Impact on Their Rights
6 The Situation and Protection of Indigenous Territories
7 Cultural Identity of Indigenous Peoples
13 Freedoms of Belief, Expression, Assembly, and Association
1 Introduction
2 Freedom of Belief
2.1 Background: Paradigmatic Cases of Freedom of Belief Violations
2.2 Normative Framework
2.3 The Protection of the Freedom of Belief under the Inter-American System of Human Rights
2.3.1 Impermissible Limitations to Freedom of Belief
2.3.2 Freedom of Religion and Indigenous Peoples
2.3.3 Freedom of Religion in the Context of Counterterrorism Measures and Policies
2.3.4 The Intersection of Freedom of Belief and Freedom of Expression
3 Freedom of Thought and Expression (Article 13)
3.1 Patterns of Violation of the Right to Freedom of Thought and Expression in the Americas
3.2 Normative Framework
3.3 Mechanisms of Protection: The Office of the Special Rapporteur for Freedom of Expression
3.4 Protection of the Freedom of Thought and Expression in the Inter-American Human Rights System
3.4.1 Criminalization of Speech and Proportionality
3.4.1.1 The Case of Kimel v. Argentina: Content and Scope of Permissible Restrictions on Freedom of Expression
3.4.2 Censorship
3.4.3 Violence and Harassment against Journalists and Media Outlets
3.4.4 Hate Speech
3.4.5 The Right of Access to Information
3.4.6 The Right to Freedom of Expression and the Right to Truth
4 Freedoms of Assembly and Association
4.1 Legal Framework
4.2 Case Law of the Inter-American System of Human Rights on the Rights to Freedom of Assembly and Association
4.2.1 Violence against Unionists
4.2.2 Mass Dismissal of Protesting Workers
4.2.3 The Intersection between the Freedom of Expression and the Freedoms of Assembly and Association
14 Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights
1 Introduction
2 ESCR: Definitions and Instruments
2.1 Background and Legal Framework
2.1.1 Inter-American Instruments Related to the Protection of ESCR
2.1.2 ESCR: Progressive or Immediate Application?
2.1.2.1 Progressivity in the U.N. System
2.2 The Justiciability of ESCR
3 Direct Litigation of ESCR
3.1 The Adoption of Regressive Measures and Article 26 Jurisprudence in the Inter-American System
3.1.1 Emerging Standards to Review Alleged Impermissibly Regressive Measures
3.2 The Adjudication of Allegations of Violations of the San Salvador Protocol
4 The Use of Civil and Political Rights (Indirect Approach)
4.1 Addressing the ESCR of Children
4.2 Addressing the Right to Health
4.3 Addressing the ESCR of Indigenous Peoples
5 Cross-Cutting Approaches to the Protection of ESCR
6 Considering Litigation as Only One of Several Tools to Promote ESCR
7 Additional Mechanisms for the Supervision of the Implementation of ESCR: The Reporting System under Article 19 of the Protocol of San Salvador
7.1 New Developments: the New Special Rapporteurship on ESCR
Part Three Beyond Judgment—Reparations, Compliance, and the Future of the Inter-American System
Preliminary Material
15 Reparations and Compliance
1 Introduction
2 The Inter-American Commission and Reparations
2.1 Reports on the Merits and Reparations
2.2 Forms of Reparation
2.3 Reparations Recommended to Address Violations of Economic, Social. and Cultural Rights
2.4 Friendly Settlements and Reparations
2.4.1 Friendly Settlements Addressing Violations of Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights
2.5 Compliance with the Commission’s Recommendations and Friendly Settlements
2.5.1 Economic, Social, Political, and Legal Factors That Affect Compliance
3 The Inter-American Court and Reparations
3.1 The Concepts of Victim and Injured Party
3.1.1 Flexible Concept of Next of Kin
3.1.2 Culturally Sensitive Concept of Victim
3.2 Forms of Reparation
3.2.1 Redressing Large-Scale Violations of Civil and Political Rights
3.2.2 Redressing Violations of ESCR
3.3 Compliance with the Court’s Reparations Orders
3.3.1 Legal Foundations and Monitoring Process
3.3.2 Achieving Compliance
3.3.2.1 Compliance with Restitution Orders
3.3.2.2 Compliance with Compensation Orders
3.3.2.3 Compliance with the Order to Investigate, Prosecute, and Punish Perpetrators
3.3.2.4 Compliance with Rehabilitation Orders
3.3.2.5 Compliance with Satisfaction Orders
3.3.2.6 Compliance with Guarantees of Non-repetition
4 Conclusions
16 The Future of the Inter-American Human Rights System
1 A Framework for Thinking about the Future of the Inter-American System
2 The Changing Profile of the System and Thematic Challenges and New Actors
2.1 Proposals for Improved Protections of Human Rights and Deeper Impact of the Commission and Court
3 Budgetary Challenges and Lack of Universal Ratification of the Convention: Two Obstacles to the Adequate Implementation of Human Rights Protections
3.1 Obstacles to Ratification in the United States and Canada
4 The Threat of Denunciation: How Hard Should the System Push for States Parties to Implement Human Rights Obligations?
5 A New Landscape of Regional Influence: The OAS and Competing Initiatives
5.1 Other Regional Bodies: Alternatives or Complements to the OAS and the Inter-American Human Rights System
5.2 A Move to Harmonize Human Rights Interpretations in the Region? MERCOSUR States Request an Advisory Opinion
6 Universalizing the Human Rights System, Centralizing the Interpretation of Human Rights Obligations
7 Concluding Considerations
Further Material
Index of Cases
Index
Sign up for alerts
Part Three Beyond Judgment—Reparations, Compliance, and the Future of the Inter-American System, Preliminary Material
James L. Cavallaro, Claret Vargas, Clara Sandoval, Bernard Duhaime, Caroline Bettinger-Lopez, Stephanie Erin Brewer, Diana Guzmán, Cecilia Naddeo
From:
Doctrine, Practice, and Advocacy in the Inter-American Human Rights System
James L. Cavallaro, Claret Vargas, Clara Sandoval, Bernard Duhaime, Caroline Bettinger-Lopez, Stephanie Erin Brewer, Diana Guzman, Cecilia Naddeo
Content type:
Book content
Product:
Oxford Scholarly Authorities on International Law [OSAIL]
Published in print:
01 August 2019
ISBN:
9780190900861
Prev
|
Next
[3.230.173.249]
3.230.173.249