ORIL March New Cases
March 31, 2025
In March 2025, 83 new case reports were added to Oxford Reports on International Law. This update included 54 ILDC headnotes, 15 ICL headnotes, and 14 IHRL headnotes.
Cases
| OUP ID | Title | Author |
|---|---|---|
| ILDC 3329 (DE 2021) | Appeal decision, 5 A 486/19.A; ILDC 3329 (DE 2021); BeckRS 2021, 32143; ECLI:DE:OVGSN:2021:1006.5A486.19.A.00, 6 October 2021 | Paula Rhein-Fischer |
| ILDC 3465 (DE 2022) | A v Germany, Military support for Ukraine v imperative of peace under the German Constitution and the United Nations Charter, Order, urgent legal remedy, VG 6 L 228/22; ILDC 3465 (DE 2022), 12 December 2022 | Rosa Maria Weißer |
| ILDC 3528 (RU 2023) | On refusing to accept for consideration the citizen Markus’s complaint on the violation of her constitutional rights by part one of Article 20.3.3. of the Code of the Russian Federation on administrative offences, Constitutional proceedings, No 1387-O; ILDC 3528 (RU 2023), 30 May 2023 | Sergey Marochkin, Rustam Khalafyan |
| ILDC 3373 (PA 2012) | Sabrina Bacal Securansky v The Second Superior Tribunal of the First Judicial District of Panama, Amparo for constitutional rights protection, 1292-10; ILDC 3373 (PA 2012), 4 July 2012 | Gianfranco Smith |
| ILDC 3469 (UK 2023) | The Law Debenture Trust Corporation plc (Appellant) v Ukraine (Represented by the Minister of Finance of Ukraine acting upon the instructions of the Cabinet Ministers of Ukraine) (Respondent), Appeal judgment, Case ID: 2018/0192, [2023] UKSC 11; ILDC 3469 (UK 2023), 15 March 2023 | Batuhan Betin |
| ILDC 3431 (TZ 2023) | Benjamin T Mangula & 20 Others v Tanzania Zambia Railway Authority and Another, Judgment, Application No 418 of 2022; [2023] TZHCLD 1142; ILDC 3431 (TZ 2023), 9 March 2023 | Nnenna Mazi |
| ILDC 3522 (CN 2016) | Zhang Yubai medical negligence liability case, Zhang Yubai v People’s Hospital of Chengdu Jinniu District and People’s Hospital of Sichuan Province, Final appeal judgment, (2016) Chuan 01 Min Zhong No 11274; ILDC 3522 (CN 2016), 15 December 2016 |
Ying Sun |
| ILDC 3422 (DE 2021) | Order, Constitutional complaint, final Case No 1 BvR 1541/20, ILDC 3422 (DE 2021); Reports Vol 160, 79; NVwZ 2022, 139; NJW 2022, 380; MedR 2022, 212; DÖV 2022, 300; EuGRZ 2022, 125; JZ 2022, 145; RDG 2022, 91, 16 December 2021 | Markus Vordermayer-Riemer |
| ILDC 3531 (UA 2019) | Khilko Andrii Anatoliyovych v Candidate for the post of President of Ukraine Volodymyr Oleksandrovich Zelenskyi, First instance judgment, No 855/119/19; ILDC 3531 (UA 2019), 17 April 2019 | Vasyl Hostyuk |
| ILDC 3566 (MY 2023) | Samat bin Yamin v Public Prosecutor, Final judgment on bail application, [2023] 4 MLJ 613; ILDC 3566 (MY 2023); [2023] 6 CLJ 1; [2022] MLJU 3670, 5 October 2022 | Stewart Manley, Kashmeera Balamurale |
| ILDC 3462 (DE 2023) | Afghan Asylum Seeker v Germany, Appeal judgment, A 11 S 1329/20; ILDC 3462 (DE 2023); Asylmagazin 2023, 159-163; InfAuslR 2023, 237-251; BeckRS 2023, 3324; openJur 2023, 3985, 22 February 2023 | Valentin Büchi |
| ILDC 3523 (BD 2000) | Mohd Akhtaruzzaman v Bangladesh and Ors, Writ petition, NO 3774 of 1999; ILDC 3523 (BD 2000); (2006) 3 LG (HCD) 49, 15 March 2000 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3467 (DE 2023) | Prisoner Remuneration No 2, Decision on Constitutional Complaint, 2 BvR 166/16, 2 BvR 1683/17, ILDC 3467 (DE 2023), 20 June 2023 | Justine Batura |
| ILDC 3544 (DE 2023) | Retrial to the disadvantage of the exoneree, A, Constitutional complaint, 2 BvR 900/22, ILDC 3544 (DE 2023), NJW 2023, 3698, 31 October 2023 | Btissam Boulakhrif |
| ILDC 3578 (UK 2021) | “Maduro Board” of the Central Bank of Venezuela v “Guaidó Board” of the Central Bank of Venezuela, Final appeal judgment, [2021] UKSC 57; ILDC 3578, 20 December 2021 | William Fortin |
| ILDC 3602 (SI 2018) | Applicant v Slovenia, Revision, Supreme Court’s judgement II Ips 296/2017; ILDC 3602 (SI 2018); 15 March 2018 | Andreja Friškovec |
| ILDC 3622 (CA 1994) | MacMillan Bloedel Ltd v Russow, Judgment on application for leave to appeal an order refusing to vary an interlocutory order, Docket No VI01984; 1994 CanLII 263; ILDC 3622 (CA 1994); [1994] BCJ No 3349, 7 December 1994 | Gerard Kennedy |
| ILDC 3621 (CA 2021) | Environnement Jeunesse v Canada (Attorney General), Appeal judgment, 2021 QCCA 1871; ILDC 3621 (CA 2021), 13 December 2021 | Gillian MacNeil |
| ILDC 3617 (TR 2021) | Turkey v Cuma El Suleyman, Emin El Suleyman, Fuad Alsuleyman, Halid El Suleyman, Zekeriya Casim, Abdurrahman El Halef, First instance decision, Case No 2019/425; Decision No 2021/44; ILDC 3617 (TR 2021), 22 January 2021 | Ali Kerem Kayhan |
| ILDC 3099 (BD 1977) | Bangladesh v Unamarayen SA Panama and others, Civil appellate decision, Appeal from Original Order No 219 of 1977 and Civil Rule No 639 (fm) of 1977, (1977) 29 DLR (HCD) 252, ILDC 3099 (BD 1977); 26 DLR (SC) 44, 16 June 1977 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3304 (BD 2020) | Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association (BELA) v Government of Bangladesh and Others (2020), Writ petition, Writ Petition No 1863 of 2014; ILDC 3304 (BD 2020), 2 December 2020 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3664 (IN 2024) | Nipun Malhotra v Sony Pictures Films India Private Limited & Ors, Special Leave Petition (Civil), No 5239 of 2024; ILDC 3664 (IN 2024); 2024 INSC 465, 08 July 2024 | Surendra Kumar |
| ILDC 3397 (BD 2022) | Lutfor Rahaman v State and others, Criminal leave petition, (2022) Criminal Appeal (H) 10852/2019; ILDC 3397 (BD 2022), 28 August 2022 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3603 (CN 2004) | Dalian Oceanic Fisheries Co, Ltd v Liaoning Dalian Ocean Fishing Industry Group Co, Ltd, First instance judgment, (2004) Da Hai Ba Shang Chu Zi No 12; ILDC 3603 (CN 2004), 12 October 2004 | Ying Sun |
| ILDC 3559 (BD 2023) | Niko Resources (Bangladesh) Limited v Professor M Shamsul Alam and others, Civil petition for leave to appeal, No 4506 of 2017; ILDC 3559 (BD 2023), 18 June 2023 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3550 (DE 2021) | A v Germany, Appeal decision, 9 A 1489/20.A, ILDC 3550 (DE 2021), 10 May 2021 | Btissam Boulakhrif |
| ILDC 3644 (UK 2024) | Argentum Exploration Ltd v Republic of South Africa, Judgment, UKSC 16; ILDC 3644 (UK 2024), 8 May 2024 | Ankit Malhotra |
| ILDC 3545 (DE 2023) | Germany v Mainstream, Appeal decision, BGH I ZB 43/22, ILDC 3545 (DE 2023); NJW 2023, 3501; SchiedsVZ 2023, 289; WM 2023, 1564; EuZW 2023, 997; IWRZ 2023, 282; BeckRS 2023, 19617; 27 July 2023 | Salman Khan |
| ILDC 3631 (UA 2013) | International Charitable Organization ‘Environment-People-Law’ v the Ministry of Environmental Protection of Ukraine, First instance judgment, No 826/6201/13-а, ILDC 3631 (UA 2013), 19 July 2013 | Vasyl Hostyuk |
| ILDC 3669 (AT 2019) | Anonymous v Vienna, Final Appeal/Cassation, E 576/2019-9; ILDC 3669 (AT 2021); Jus-Extra VfGH 2020, 5, 11 June 2019 | Fritz Kainz |
| ILDC 3572 (BD 2020) | Nishat Jute Mills Limited v Human Rights and Peace for Bangladesh (HRPB) and others, Appeal final decision, Civil Petition No 3039 of 2019-(SC) AD; ILDC 3572 (BD 2020), 17 February 2020 | Quazi Omar Foysal |
| ILDC 3648 (MY 2023) | Ow Man Yaw & Ors v Ministry of Home Affairs & Anor, First judgment, [2024] 9 MLJ 77; ILDC 3648 (MY 2023), 14 September 2023 | Stewart Manley, Wan Nabilah Dina binti Wan Zamri |
| ILDC 3610 (UK 2024) | Graham William Philips v Secretary of State for Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Affairs, Judgment, [2024] EWHC 32 (Admin), AC-2023-LON-1868; ILDC 3608 (UK 2024), 12 January 2024 | Richard Wagenlander |
| ILDC 3628 (NG 2018) | Centre for Oil Pollution Watch v Nigerian National Petroleum Corporation, Supreme Court judgment, SC 319/2013; (2019) 5 NWLR 1666; ILDC 3628 (NG 2018), 20 July 2018 | Nnenna Mazi |
| ILDC 3453 (BD 2017) | World Bank Office, Dhaka and others v Ismet Zerin Khan (2017), Civil revision, Civil Revision No 3352 of 2011; 37 BLD (HCD) 208; ILDC 3453 (BD 2017), 12 March 2017 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3524 (IT 2022) | Federazione Italiana Lavoratori Commercio Turismo Servizi (FILCAMS) v United States of America, Final appeal judgment, No 2849/2022; ILDC 3524 (IT 2022), 31 January 2022 | Pierfrancesco Rossi |
| ILDC 3552 (DE 2023) | VGH Baden-Württemberg, Appeal decision, A 10 S 400/23, ILDC 3552 (DE 2023); openJur 2023, 10094; ECLI:DE:VGHBW:2023:0712.A10S400.23.00, 12 July 2023 | Sören Zimmermann |
| ILDC 2983 (RO 2017) | Plaintiffs v the Generale Inspectorate of the Romanian Police, Preliminary decision, File no 4151/1/2016; Decision no 30/2017, ILDC 2983 (RO 2017); Official Gazette, Part I no 509 of 3 July 2017, 15 May 2017 | Maria Beatrice Berna |
| ILDC 3555 (DE 2023) | Works council v Employer, Appeal decision, LAG 7 TaBV 1/23, ILDC 3555 (DE 2023); BeckRS 2023, 34472; FD-ArbR 2023, 034472; NZA-RR 2024, 168; 14 June 2023 | Salman Khan |
| ILDC 3627 (IE 2020) | Friends of the Irish Environment v Government of Ireland, Ireland and the Attorney General, Final appeal judgment, Supreme Court judgment [2020] IESC 49; ILDC 3627 (IE 2020), 31 July 2020 | Rory Sugrue |
| ILDC 3410 (US 2022) | Paresh Kumar Bhaktibhai-Patel v Garland, Appeal judgment, 32 F4th 180 (2d Cir 2022); ILDC 3410 (US 2022), 27 April 2022 | Arman Becan |
| ILDC 3547 (DE 2023) | Rosneft v Federal Republic of Germany, Judgment, first and last instance, Bundesverwaltungsgericht (Federal Administrative Court), 8 A 2.22; ILDC 3547 (DE 2023), 14 March 2023 | Lena Herzog |
| ILDC 3641 (DE 2024) | Decision in a detention review, BGH AK4/24; ILDC 3641 (DE 2024), 21 February 2024 | Lena Herzog |
| ILDC 3409 (US 2022) | Salame v Tescari, Appeal judgment, 29 F4th 763 (6th Cir 2022); ILDC 3409 (US 2022), 29 March 2022 | Rachel Hauser |
| ILDC 3413 (US 2022) | Golan v Saada, Supreme Court judgment, 142 S Ct 1880 (2022); ILDC 3413 (US 2022), 15 June 2022 | David Naftulin |
| ILDC 3500 (UK 2022) | Bright Uhunamure v Belgium, Appeal judgment, [2021] EWHC 2435; ILDC 3500 (UK 2022), 30 September 2022 | William Fortin |
| ILDC 3261 (BD 2021) | Md Ataur Rahman v Government of Bangladesh and Others, Writ jurisdiction, Writ Petition No 824 of 2021; ILDC 3261 (BD 2021), 16 March 2021 | Md Rizwanul Islam |
| ILDC 3642 (IT 2023) | Criminal Proceedings against Sabir Tariq, Ibrahim Mohamed Athar Kamel, Helmi Uhsam, Sharif Abdelal Magdi Ibrahim, Incidental judgment of constitutionality, Constitutional Court, No 192/2023; ILDC 3642 (IT 2023), 26 October 2023 | Giulio Nessi and Riccardo Pavoni |
| ILDC 3667 (MY 2024) | MPPL & Anor v CAS, Final appeal judgment, Civil Appeal No. 02(f)-49-08 of 2023(W), [2024] 4 MLJ 524; ILDC 3667 (MY 2024), 3 July 2024 | Stewart Manley and Anisah binti Norman Ismadi Omar |
| ILDC 3455 (DE 2022) | European Patent Office, legal entity and ors v Germany, Order on constitutional complaint, 2 BvR 2480/10, 2 BvR 421/13, 2 BvR 756/16, 2 BvR 786/15, 2 BvR 561/18; ILDC 3455 (DE 2022); BVerfGE 163, 363; GRUR 2023, 549; MittdtschPatAnw 2023, 69; NVwZ 2023, 595, 8 November 2022 | Valentin Büchi |
| ILDC 3579 (FR 2023) | City of Grande Synthe v France, Execution proceeding, case n° 467982; ILDC 3579 (FR 2023), 10 May 2023 | Julie Cardon |
| ILDC 2663 (US 2016) | Animal Science Products, Inc and the Ranis Company, Inc v Hebei Welcome Pharmaceutical Co Ltd and North China Pharmaceutical Group Corporation, Appeal judgment, 873 F3d 175 (2d Cir 2016); ILDC 2663 (US 2016), 20 September 2016 | Holden Fitzgerald |
| ILDC 3635 (CO 2022) | The Raizal People of San Andrés and Santa Catalina and others v Presidency of the Republic, Appeal for protection (‘Acción de Tutela’), T-333 of 2022; ILDC 3635 (CO 2023), 26 September 2022 | Emerson Harvey Cepeda-Rodríguez |
| ILDC 3665 (AR 1983) | Julio Efraín Washington Cabrera v Comisión Técnica Mixta de Salto Grande, Extraordinary appeal, CSJN Fallos 305:2150; ILDC 3665 (AR 1983), 5 December 1983 | María José Escobar Gil |
| ICL 164 (ICTY 2015) | Prosecutor v Stanišić and Simatović, Judgment; Case No IT-03-69-A; ICL 164 (ICTY 2015), 9 December 2015 | Elizabeth Santalla Vargas |
| ICL 2086 (ICC 2021) | Situation in the Central African Republic II, Prosecutor v Alfred Yekatom and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, Public redacted version of ‘Judgement on Mr Yekatom’s appeal against Trial Chamber V’s “Decision on the Yekatom Defence’s Admissibility Challenge”’, 9 October 2020, ICC-01/14-01/18-678-Conf, Case no ICC-01/14-01/18 OA; ICL 2086 (ICC 2021), 11 February 2021 | Andreja Friškovec |
| ICL 2181 (KSC 2023) | Specialist Prosecutor v Thaҫi and ors, Decision on Defence Motion for Judicial Notice of Adjudicated Facts with Annex 1 (public), Case No KSC-BC-2020-06/F01536; ICL 2181 (KSC 2023), 18 May 2023 | Elizabeth Santalla Vargas |
| ICL 2165 (KSC 2023) | Specialist Prosecutor v Shala, Decision on victims’ procedural rights during trial and related matters, Case No KSC-BC-2020-04/F00433; ICL 2165 (KSC 2023), 24 February 2023 | Elizabeth Santalla Vargas |
| ICL 2171 (ICC 2023) | Situation in the Republic of Philippines, Public Redacted Version of ‘Authorisation pursuant to article 18(2) of the Statute to resume the investigation’, Situation no ICC-01/21-56-Red, ICL 2171 (ICC 2023), 26 January 2023 | Tibor Bajnovič |
| ICL 2173 (ICC 2023) | Situation in the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan, Judgment on the Prosecutor’s appeal against the decision of Pre-Trial Chamber II entitled “Decision pursuant to article 18(2) of the Statute authorising the Prosecution resume investigation”, Situation no ICC-02/17-218, ICL 2173 (ICC 2021), 4 April 2023 | Tibor Bajnovič |
| ICL 2164 (KSC 2023) | Prosecutor v Hashim Thaҫi, Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi, and Jakup Krasniqi, Decision on Selimi Defence Request Regarding Further Initial Appearance, Preliminary Motions and Suspension of Alibi Notice Deadline, KSC-BC-2020-06, ICL 2164 (KSC 2023), 22 February 2023 | Alice Lopes Fabris |
| ICL 2154 (ICC 2022) | Situation in the Central African Republic II, Prosecutor v Mahamat Said Abdel Kani, Decision on the admissibility of the appeal, Case no ICC-01/14-01/21 OA5; ICL 2154 (ICC 2022), 25 October 2022 | Andreja Friškovec |
| ICL 2178 (ICC 2023) | Situation in the Central African Republic II, Prosecutor v Alfred Yekatom and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, Public redacted version of “Decision on the ‘Application for Judicial Review of the Registrar’s “Decision on the Request for Review by Mr Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona concerning certain issues of food in detention”’, dated 17 May 2023 (ICC-RoR220-02/23-1-Conf)” dated 7 August 2023 (ICC-RoR220-02/23-3-Conf-Exp), Case no ICC-RoR220-02/23; ICL 2178 (ICC 2023), 13 September 2023 | Andreja Friškovec |
| ICL 2192 (ICC 2023) |
Situation in Uganda, Prosecutor v Dominic Ongwen, Decision designating a State of enforcement, Case no ICC-02/04-01/15-2065; ICL 2192 (ICC 2024), 9 November 2023 |
Andreja Friškovec |
| ICL 2160 (KSC 2023) | Specialist Prosecutor v Gucati and Haradinaj, Appeal judgment, Case No KSC-CA-2022-01/F00114; ICL 2160 (KSC 2023), 2 February 2023 | Elizabeth Santalla Vargas |
| ICL 2204 (KSC 2023) | Prosecutor v Januzi and Bahtjari, Corrected Version of Public Redacted Version of the Decision on the Confirmation of the Indictment, Case No KSC-BC-2023-10/F00008/Red/Cor, ICL 2204 (KSC 2023), 2 October 2023 (corrected version of public redacted version, 12 October 2023) | Elizabeth Santalla Vargas |
| ICL 2191 (ICC 2023) | Situation in the Central African Republic II, Prosecutor v Alfred Yekatom and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, Decision on the ‘Application for Judicial Review of Registrar's Decision of 23 May 2023’, Case no ICC-RoR220-03/23, ICL 2175 (ICC 2023), 13 September 2023 | Ahmed Abdelaziem |
| ICL 2203 (KSC 2023) | Specialist Prosecutor v Thaҫi and ors, Decision on Prosecution Motion for Admission of Evidence pursuant to Rule 155, Case No KSC-BC-2020-06/F01603/Red; ICL 2203 (KSC 2023), 14 June 2023 (public redacted version 8 September 2023) | Elizabeth Santalla Vargas |
| ICL 2168 (KSC 2023) | Prosecutor v Hashim Thaҫi, Kadri Veseli, Rexhep Selimi, and Jakup Krasniqi, Decision Regarding Cross-Examination by Victims’ Counsel, KSC-BC-2020-06, ICL 2168 (KSC 2023), 9 March 2023 |
Alice Lopes Fabris |
| IHRL 4393 (ACtHPR 2024) | John Mwita v Tanzania, Merits and reparations, App no 044/2016; IHRL 4393 (ACtHPR 2024), 13 February 2024 |
Charlene Ama Debrah |
| IHRL 4391 (ACtHPR 2023) | Swagga v Tanzania, Merits and reparations, App no 014/2017; IHRL 4391 (ACHPR 2023), 7 November 2023 |
Elim Shanko |
| IHRL 4398 (ACtHPR 2024) | Jeshi v Tanzania, Merits and reparations, App no 017/2016; IHRL 4398 (ACtHPR 2024), 13 February 2024 | Irene Pamblanco Esteve |
| IHRL 4415 (ACtHPR 2024) | Dominick Damian v Tanzania, United Republic of, Merits and reparations, App no 048/2016; IHRL 4415 (ACtHPR 2024), 4 June 2024 | Linah A. Aduda |
| IHRL 4426 (ACtHPR 2024) | Lompo v Burkina Faso, Ruling (Jurisdiction and Admissibility), App no 016/2019; IHRL 4426 (ACtHPR 2024), 3 September 2024 | Kouity Tiétoun Lesline Grâce |
| IHRL 4332 (ECHR 2023) | Georgia v Russia (II), Just satisfaction, App no 38263/08; IHRL 4332 (ECHR 2023), 28 April 2023 | Giorgi Nakashidze |
| IHRL 4222 (ECHR 2021) | Behar and Gutman v Bulgaria, Admissibility, merits and just satisfaction, App No 29335/13; IHRL 4222 (ECHR 2021), 16 February 2021 |
Mariana Monteiro de Matos |
| IHRL 4373 (ECHR 2023) | Y v France, Merits and Just satisfaction, App No 76888/17; IHRL 4373 (ECHR 2023), 31 January 2023 | Yoleth E. Laínez Calderón |
| IHRL 4403 (IACHR 2021) | Case of Manuela et al v El Salvador, Preliminary objections, merits, reparations and costs, IACHR Series C No 441; IHRL 4403(IACHR 2021), 2 November 2021 | Amity Meng-Ting Hsieh |
| IHRL 4408 (IACHR 2020) | Case of Urrutia Laubreaux v Chile, Preliminary objections, Merits, reparations and costs, IACHR Series C No 409; IHRL 4408 (IACHR 2020), 27 August 2020 | Rodrigo Cespedes |
| IHRL 4410 (IACHR 2021) | Case of the Former Employees of the Judiciary v Guatemala, Preliminary objections, merits and reparations, IACHR Series C No 445; IHRL 4410 (IACHR 2021), 17 November 2021 | Martin Baumgartner |
| IHRL 4411 (IACHR 2021) | Case of the Village of Los Josefinos Massacre v Guatemala, Preliminary objection, merits, reparations and costs, IACHR Series C No 442; IHRL 4411 (IACHR 2021), 3 November 2021 | Giorgi Baidze |
| IHRL 4437 (IACHR 2022) | Case of Huacón Baidal and ors v Ecuador, Approval of friendly settlement agreement, IACHR Series No 466; IHRL 4437(IACHR 2022), 4 October 2022 | Haris Huremagić |
| IHRL 4115 (IACHR 2009) | Case of Kawas Fernández v Honduras, Fernández and ors v Honduras, Merits, reparations and costs, IACHR Series C no 196; IHRL 4115 (IACHR 2009), 3 April 2009 | Carlos Valdivia and Shahna Esber |
