Jump to Content Jump to Main Navigation

October New Cases

October 14, 2021

Oxford Reports on International Law adds 48 new cases. 

Cases 

 

Case name Reporter / Author OUP ID
Prosecutor v Brima et alia, Decision on Joint Defence Appeal against the Decision on the Report of the Independent Counsel Pursuant to Rule 77 (C) (iii) and 77 (D), Case no SCSL-04-16-AR77; ICL 1127 (SCSL 2005), 17 August 2005 Brenda Mwale  ICL 1127 (SCSL 2005)
Prosecutor v Norman et al, Decision and order on Prosecution motions for joinder, Case nos SCSL-2003-08-PT; SCSL-2003-11-PT; SCSL-2003-12-PT, ICL 1136 (SCSL 2004) 27 January 2004 Ioana Ortance Onu  ICL 1136 (SCSL 2004)
Prosecutor v Charles Ghankay Taylor, Decision on Prosecution Motion for Admission of Documents of the United Nations and United Nations Bodies, SCSL-03-1-T; ICL 1139 (SCSL 2009), 20 February 2009 Damian Etone ICL 1139 (SCSL 2009)
Prosecutor v Ayyash, Decision on defence preliminary motion challenging jurisdiction, Case no STL-18-10/PT/TC; ICL 1154 (STL 2020), 10 September 2020 Stella Nasirumbi
 
ICL 1154 (STL 2020)
Prosecutor v Ayyash, Decision on defence appeal against ‘decision on defence preliminary motion challenging jurisdiction’, Case no STL-18-10/PT/AC/AR90.1; ICL 1156 (STL 2020), 26 October 2020 Matthew Kearney ICL 1156 (STL 2020)
Situation in the Central African Republic, Prosecutor v Bemba et ors., Decision on the scope of the appeal of Mr Jean-Pierre Bemba, Case no ICC-01/05-01/13-2337; ICL 1955 (ICC 2019), 20 August 2019 Daniel Eck ICL 1955 (ICC 2019)
Yekatom and Ngaïssona case, Prosecutor v Alfred Yekatom and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, Decision on the ‘Prosecution’s Request to Amend Charges pursuant to Article 61(9) and for Correction of the Decision on the Confirmation of Charges, and Notice of Intention to Add Additional Charges’, Case no ICC-01/14-01/18-517; ICL 1988 (ICC 2020), 14 May 2020 Alreem Kamal ICL 1988 (ICC 2020)
Situation in the Central African Republic II in the case of the Prosecutor v Alfred Yekatom and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, Decision on the Prosecution’s Application for Notice to be given pursuant to Regulation 55(2) on Mr Yekatom’s Individual Criminal Responsibility, Case no ICC-01/14-01/18-542; ICL 2001 (ICC 2020), 2 June 2020 Chiara Giaccari ICL 2001 (ICC 2020)
Situation in the Central African Republic II in the case of the Prosecutor v Alfred Yekatom and Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, Decision on the Ngaïssona Defence Request to Redress Violations in Detention, Case no ICC-01/14-01/18-563; ICL 2003 (ICC 2020), 22 June 2020 Chiara Giaccari ICL 2003 (ICC 2020)ICL 2003 (ICC 2020)
Specialist Prosecutor v Thaҫi and ors, Framework Decision on Disclosure of Evidence and Related Matters, Case No KSC-BC-2020-06/F00099; ICL 2020 (KSC 2020), 23 November 2020 Elizabeth Santalla Vargas ICL 2020 (KSC 2020)
Situation in Darfur, Sudan in the case of the Prosecutor v Ali Muhammad Ali Abd -Al-Rahman (‘Ali Kushayb’), Decision on the Defence Request to provide written reasoning for two oral decisions, Case no ICC-02/05-01/20; ICL 2022 (ICC 2020), 18 August 2020 Chiara Giaccari ICL 2022 (ICC 2020)
Situation in the Republic of Mali, Prosecutor v Al Hassan, Public redacted version of ‘Corrigendum of “Decision on Prosecution requests concerning the Defence motion to terminate the proceedings”’, ICC-01/12-01/18-932-Corr-Red, ICL 2023 (ICC 2020), 18 August 2020 Mari Sewell ICL 2023 (ICC 2020)
Situation in the Republic of Mali, Prosecutor v Al Hassan, Public redacted version of ‘Corrigendum of “Decision on Prosecution requests concerning the Defence motion to terminate the proceedings”’, ICC-01/12-01/18-932-Corr-Red, ICL 2023 (ICC 2020), 18 August 2020 Mari Sewell ICL 2024 (ICC 2020)
Teco Guatemala Holdings LLC v Guatemala, Decision on the claimant’s request for a supplementary decision, ICSID Case No ARB/10/23; IIC 1701 (2020), 16 October 2020 Isabella Greppi
 
ICL 2025 (ICC 2020)
RWE Innogy GmbH and RWE Innogy Aersa SAU v Spain, Decision on jurisdiction, liability, and certain issues of quantum, ICSID Case No ARB/14/34; IIC 1723 (2019), 30 December 2019 Raghavi Viswanath
 
ICL 2026 (ICC 2020)
Argentinian Bonds, Decision in a constitutional complaint, 2 BvR 824/15 + 2 BvR 825/15; ILDC 3044 (DE 2019); NJW 2019, 2761, 3 July 2019 Isabella Greppi ICL 2028 (ICC 2020)
Victor Villalba Doria and Anway v IBERIA LAE, Action of unconstitutionality, torts request and compensation for damages, Final Judgment 399/2011, ILDC 3151 (PY 2011), 20 June 2011 Theodosia Papazikou ILDC 3151 (PY 2011)
BayWa re Renewable Energy GmbH and BayWa re Asset Holding GmbH v Spain, Decision on jurisdiction, liability and directions on quantum, ICSID Case No ARB/15/16, IIC 1724 (2019), 2 December 2019   IIC 1724 (2019)
Carlos Sastre and ors v Mexico, Procedural order no 4 Document Production, ICSID Case No UNCT/20/2; IIC 1725 (2021), 16 June 2021   IIC 1725 (2021)
Peteris Pildegovics and SIA North Star v Norway, Procedural order no 3 Decision on respondent’s request for bifurcation, ICSID Case No ARB/20/11; IIC 1726 (2021), 1 June 2021   IIC 1726 (2021)
Peteris Pildegovics and SIA North Star v Norway, Procedural order no 4 Schedule of pleadings and confidentiality, ICSID Case No ARB/20/11; IIC 1727 (2021), 30 June 2021   IIC 1727 (2021)
PACC Offshore Services Holdings Ltd v Mexico, Procedural order no 4, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/5; IIC 1728 (2019), 7 November 2019   IIC 1728 (2019)
PACC Offshore Services Holdings Ltd v Mexico, Procedural order no 5 On the organization of the hearing, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/5; IIC 1729 (2021), 21 April 2021   IIC 1729 (2021)
Odyssey Marine Exploration Inc (USA) v Mexico, Procedural order no 3 Production of documents, ICSID Case No UNCT/20/1; IIC 1730 (2021), 23 April 2021   IIC 1730 (2021)
AS PNB Banka (formerly AS Norvik Banka) and ors v Republic of Latvia, Decision on the intra-EU objection, ICSID Case No ARB/17/47; IIC 1731 (2021), 14 May 2021   IIC 1731 (2021)
Metro de Lima Línea 2 SA v Peru, Decision on jurisdiction and liability, ICSID Case No ARB/17/3; IIC 1732 (2021), 6 July 2021   IIC 1732 (2021)
Grace and ors v Mexico, Procedural order no 10 Claimants’ request for execution of declarations in protective orders, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/4; IIC 1733 (2021), 16 March 2021   IIC 1733 (2021)
Grace and ors v Mexico, Procedural order no 11 Claimants’ request for the production of documents covered by the protective orders, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/4; IIC 1734 (2021), 13 May 2021   IIC 1734 (2021)
Sexual Minorities Uganda v Lively, Trial judgment, 960 F Supp 3d 304 (D Mass 2013); ILDC 2636 (US 2013), 14 August 2013 Maria Yousuf ILDC 2636 (US 2013)
Cunningham v Cunningham and ors, 237 F Supp 3d 1246 (MD Fla 2017); ILDC 2859 (US 2017), 17 February 2017 Madeline Cook, Christina Saad ILDC 2859 (US 2017)
Pliego v Hayes, Appeal decision, 843 F3d 226 (6th Cir 2016); ILDC 2916 (US 2016), 5 December 2016 Navil Infante and Rachel Gale  ILDC 2916 (US 2016)
United States v Ventre, Appeal judgment, 338 F3d 1047 (9th Cir 2003); ILDC 2917 (US 2003), 11 August 2003 Surya Iyer, Mary Beth Shults ILDC 2917 (US 2003)
Baran v Beaty, Appeal judgment, 526 F3d 1340 (11th Cir 2008); ILDC 2918 (US 2008), 9 May 2008 Alexander Kish and Shannon Barry ILDC 2918 (US 2008)
Mekhoukh v Ashcroft, Appeal judgment, 358 F3d 118 (1st Cir); ILDC 2920 (US 2004), 13 February 2004 Alexander Kish
 
ILDC 2920 (US 2004)
Foresight Energy, LLC v Certain London Market Insurance Cos and ors, Trial judgment, 311 F Supp 3d 1085; ILDC 2921 (US 2018), 25 April 2018 Kimya Sarmadi
 
ILDC 2921 (US 2018)
Alcala v Hernandez, Appeal judgment, 826 F3d 161 (4th Cir 2016); ILDC 2957 (US 2016), 15 June 2016 Michael Chaia and Keziah Groth-Tuft    ILDC 2957 (US 2016)
Taj Nahar Begum v Government of Bangladesh and Ors, (2008), Writ Jurisdiction, Writ Petition No 10466 of 2007; ILDC 3092 (BD 2008); 13 BLC (HCD) 843, 20 August 2008 Md Rizwanul Islam ILDC 3092 (BD 2008)
Muberarugo v Refugee Appeal Board and Others, Final judgment, (13427/2012); [2015] ZAWCHC 139; ILDC 3181 (ZA 2015), 17 August 2015 Marie-Louise Fehun Aren ILDC 3181 (ZA 2015)
Ruta v Minister of Home Affairs, Final judgment, (CCT02/18) [2018]; ILDC 3183 (ZA 2018); ZACC 52 2019 (3); BCLR 383 (CC) 2019; (2) SA 329 (CC), 20 December 2018 Marie-Louise Fehun Aren ILDC 3181 (ZA 2015)ILDC 3183 (ZA 2015)
Motswagae and Others v Rustenburg Local Municipality and Another, Final judgment, CCT42/12, [2013] ZACC 1; ILDC 3185 (ZA 2012), 7 February 2013 Marie-Louise Fehun Aren  ILDC 3185 (ZA 2013)
Associazione benefica di solidarietà con il popolo Palestinese and Associazione Palestinesi in Italia v RAI, Interim injunction proceedings, GR 31253/2020; ILDC 3214 (IT 2020), 5 August 2020 Elena Carpanelli ILDC 3214 (IT 2020)
On the request of the Protvinsk city court to examine the constitutionality of paragraph 5.3 of the Decree of the Moscow Region Governor ‘On the Establishment of the Regime of High Alert for Governmental Authorities and Forces of the Moscow Regional System for Preventing and Combatting Emergencies and on Other Measures Aimed at Containment of the New Coronavirus Infection on the Territory of Moscow Region’, Constitutional proceedings, Judgment, No 49-П; ILDC 3228 (RU 2020), 25 December 2020 Sergey Marochkin, Maksim Likhachev  ILDC 3228 (RU 2020)
On clarification of the Russian Federation Constitutional Court Ruling of 27 March 2012 № 8-P on the case of the constitutionality of paragraph 1 of Article 23 of the Federal Law ‘On International Treaties of the Russian Federation’, Constitutional proceedings, No 2867-O-P, 24 December 2020 Sergey Marochkin and Rustam Khalafyan  ILDC 3236 (RU 2020)
Constitutional Review of Article 282 of the Civil Code of the Kyrgyz Republic and Article 209 of the Civil Procedural Code of the Kyrgyz Republic made at the submission of citizen Osintsev Yevgeniy Vladimirovich, Decision, Decision № 16-р; ILDC 3237 (KG 2013), 23 December 2013  Hannepes Taychayev and Kamila Sulaimankulova     ILDC 3237 (KG 2013)
RWE Innogy GmbH and RWE Innogy Aersa SAU v Spain, Decision on jurisdiction, liability, and certain issues of quantum, ICSID Case No ARB/14/34; IIC 1723 (2019), 30 December 2019   Lilit Madatyan ILDC 3250 (AM 2013)