Jump to Content Jump to Main Navigation

ORIL:New Cases

November 1, 2019

Oxford Reports on International Law (ORIL) adds 47 new cases for October 2019, including: Prosecutor v Ao An, International Co-Investigating Judges’ order on Admissibility of Civil Party Applicants; Julio David Pérez Lambraño v Montería Municipality, Tutela action, Sentencia; Metro Makers and Developer Ltd v Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association and others; Trinidad Cement Limited Arawak Cement Limited (Claimants) and The State of Barbados (Defendant) and Rock Hard Cement Limited (Intervener). 

 

Case name  Reporter/Author  OUP ID 
Prosecutor v Ayyash et al, Decision on Prosecution Rule 154 Motion for the Admission of Documents Relating to Telephone Subscriber Records from the Alfa Company, Case no STL-11-01; ICL 1039 (STL 2016), 3 May 2016 Sean Shun Ming Yau ICL 1039 (STL 2016)
Prosecutor v Aloys Ndimbati, Decision on the Prosecutor’s Request for the Referral of the Case of Aloys Ndimbati to Rwanda, Case no ICTR-95-1F-R11bis; ICL 1088 (ICTR 2012), 25 June 2012 Silvina Sánchez Mera ICL 1088 (ICTR 2012)
Prosecutor v Fofana and Kondewa, Judgment, Case no SCSL-04-14-T; ICL 109 (SCSL 2007),    2 August 2007 Elizabeth Santalla Vargas ICL 109  (SCSL 2007)
Prosecutor v Augustin Ngirabatware, Decision on Motion to Quash and Revise a Decision of the Registrar on Level of Complexity and Seeking Further Relief, Case no MICT-12-29-A; ICL 1090 (MICT 2014) 26 February 2014 Brenda Mwale ICL 1090 (MICT 2014)
Prosecutor v Ayyash et al, Written Reasons for Admitting into Evidence Twenty Two Documents Upon the Sabra Defence Application, Case no STL 11-01/T/TC; ICL 1104 (STL2018), 15 February 2018 Wahida Omari  ICL 1104 (STL 2018)
Lubanga case, Prosecutor v Thomas Lubanga Dyilo, Corrected version of the “Decision Setting the Size of the Reparations Award for which Thomas Lubanga Dyilo is Liable”, Case no ICC-01/04-01/06, ICL 1814 (ICC 2017), 15 December 2017* (corrected version  21 December 2017) Marthe Riché ICL 1814 (ICC 2017)
Situation in the Central African Republic, Prosecutor v Bemba and ors., Decision on Bemba Request regarding the Employment Conditions of Defence Staff, Case no ICC-01/05-01/13-2301; ICL 1877 (ICC 2018), 17 July 2018 Daniel Eck ICL 1877 (ICC 2018)
Prosecutor v Ao An, International Co-Investigating Judges’ order on Admissibility of Civil Party Applicants, Case no 004/2/07-09-2009/ECCC/OCIJ; ICL 1891 (ECCC 2018), 16 August 2018 Rita Yip ICL 1891 (ECCC 2018)
Prosecutor v Ao An and Yim Tith, Notice of Provisional Discontinuance Regarding Individual Allegations, ICL 1892 (ECCC 2018), 25 August 2016 Rita Yip ICL 1892 (ECCC 2018)
The Presidency, Public redacted version of “Decision on the request to review the decision of the Registrar denying the inclusion of an applicant in the list of counsel”, Case no ICC-RoC72-03/18; ICL 1911 (ICC 2018), 15 November 2018 Eniko Sandor ICL 1911 (ICC 2018) 
Prosecutor v Karera, Judgment, Case no ICTR-01-74-A; ICL 691 (ICTR 2009), 2 February 2009 Damian Etone ICL 691 (ICTR 2009)
Global Telecom Holding SAE v Canada, Procedural Order No 4, Decision on the Claimant’s Objections to the Respondent’s Claims of Privilege, ICSID Case No ARB/16/16; IIC 1554 (2018), 3 November 2018   IIC 1554 (2018)
Victor Pey Casado and Foundation President Allende v Republic of Chile, Decision on the respondent’s request for clarification regarding the decision on the stay of the enforcement of the award, ICSID Case No ARB/98/2; IIC 1556 (2019), 9 July 2019   IIC 1556 (2019)
Bridgestone Licensing Services Inc and Bridgestone Americas Inc v Panama, Procedural order no 11, ICSID Case No ARB/16/34; IIC 1557 (2019), 28 June 2019   IIC 1557 (2019)
Bridgestone Licensing Services Inc and Bridgestone Americas Inc v Panama, Procedural order no 12, ICSID Case No ARB/16/34; IIC 1558 (2019), 11 July 2019   IIC 1558 (2019)
The Estate of Julio Miguel Orlandini-Agreda and Compañía Minera Orlandini Ltda v Bolivia, Decision on the respondent’s application for termination, trifurcation and security for costs, PCA Case No 2018-39; IIC 1559 (2019), 9 July 2019   IIC 1559 (2019)
ICW Europe Investments Limited v Czech Republic, Award, PCA Case No 2014-22; IIC 1560 (2019), 15 May 2019   IIC 1560 (2019)
Photovoltaik Knopf Betriebs-GMBH v Czech Republic, Award, PCA Case No 2014-21; IIC 1561 (2019), 15 May 2019   IIC 1561 (2019)
WA Investments-Europa Nova Limited v Czech Republic, Award, PCA Case No 2014-19; IIC 1562 (2019), 15 May 2019   IIC 1562 (2019)
B-Mex, LLC and ors v Mexico, Partial Award and Partial Dissenting Opinion, ICSID Case No ARB(AF)/16/3; IIC 1564 (2019), 19 July 2019   IIC 1564 (2019)
Bay View Group LLC and The Spalena Company LLC v Republic of Rwanda, Procedural order no 2 on bifurcation, ICSID Case No ARB/18/21; IIC 1565 (2019), 28 June 2019   IIC 1565 (2019)
Global Telecom Holding SAE v Canada, Procedural Order No 7, Hearing Organization, ICSID Case No ARB/16/16; IIC 1566 (2019), 14 March 2019   IIC 1566 (2019)
Global Telecom Holding SAE v Canada, Procedural Order No 9, ICSID Case No ARB/16/16; IIC 1567 (2019), 25 March 2019   IIC 1567 (2019)
Joshua Dean Nelson and Jorge Luis Blanco v Mexico, Procedural Order No 15, ICSID Case No UNCT/17/1; IIC 1568 (2019), 9 July 2019   IIC 1568 (2019)
Grace and ors v Mexico, Procedural Order No 1, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/4; IIC 1569 (2019), 25 March 2019   IIC 1569 (2019)
Grace and ors v Mexico, Procedural Order No 2, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/4; IIC 1570 (2019), 5 April 2019   IIC 1570 (2019)
Grace and ors v Mexico, Procedural Order No 3 on confidentiality, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/4; IIC 1571 (2019), 26 April 2019   IIC 1571 (2019)
Grace and ors v Mexico, Procedural Order No 4 Decision on the ad hoc group of bondholders’ application for leave to intervene, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/4; IIC 1572 (2019), 24 June 2019   IIC 1572 (2019)
United Utilities (Tallinn) BV and Aktsiaselts Tallina Vesi v Estonia, Award and Dissenting Opinion, ICSID Case No ARB/14/24; IIC 1575 (2019), 21 June 2019   IIC 1575 (2019)
Rockhopper Italia SpA, Rockhopper Mediterranean Ltd and Rockhopper Exploration Plc v Italy, Decision on the intra-EU jurisdictional objection, ICSID Case No ARB/17/14; IIC 1576 (2019), 26 June 2019   IIC 1576 (2019)
Gran Colombia Gold Corp v Colombia, Procedural order no 1, ICSID Case No ARB/18/23; IIC 1577 (2019), 24 June 2019   IIC 1577 (2019)
Gran Colombia Gold Corp v Colombia, Procedural order no 2, ICSID Case No ARB/18/23; IIC 1578 (2019), 11 July 2019   IIC 1578 (2019)
Glencore Finance (Bermuda) Ltd v Bolivia, Procedural order no 6, PCA Case No 2016-39; IIC 1579 (2019), 31 May 2019   IIC 1579 (2019)
PT Ventures SGPS SA v Cape Verde, Order of the tribunal taking note of the discontinuance of the proceedings, ICSID Case No ARB/15/12, IIC 1585 (2019), 10th June 2019   IIC 1585 (2019)
Gramercy Funds Management LLC and Gramercy Peru Holdings LLC v Peru, Procedural order no 8, ICSID Case No UNCT/18/2, IIC 1586 (2019), 7th June 2019   IIC 1586 (2019)
Walter Bau AG (In Liquidation) v Thailand, Partial award on jurisdiction, IIC 1587 (2007), 5th October 2007   IIC 1587 (2007)
Miminco LLC and ors v Congo, the Democratic Republic of the, Award, ICSID Case No ARB/03/14, IIC 1588 (2007), 19th November 2007   IIC 1588 (2007)
Julio David Pérez Lambraño v Montería Municipality, Tutela action, Sentencia T-051/2011, T-2650185; ILDC 1841 (CO 2011), 4 February 2011 Paola Andrea Acosta Alvarado ILDC 1841 (CO 2011)
A and ors v Norwegian Immigration Appeals Board, Decision, Case No HR-2018-2133-A (2017/2179); ILDC 2935 (NO 2018), 8 November 2018 Erna Kozica ILDC 2935 (NO 2018)
Argentina v Central Criminal Court No 5, Order, AAN 1906/2018; ILDC 2947 (ES 2018), 22 October 2018 Laura Íñigo Álvarez ILDC 2947 (ES 2018)
Argentina v Central Criminal Court No 5, Order, AAN 1907/2018; ILDC 2948 (ES 2018), 22 October 2018 Laura Íñigo Álvarez ILDC 2948 (ES 2018)
Z v Minister of the Interior, Judgment, SAN 421/2017; ECLI: ES:AN:2017:3911; ILDC 2950 (ES 2017), 29 October 2017 Ana María Maestro Cortizas ILDC 2950 (ES 2017)
Metro Makers and Developer Ltd v Bangladesh Environmental Lawyers Association and others, Appeal (Final Stage), Civil Appeal No 256 of 2009;  65 DLR (AD) (2013) 181; ILDC 2980 (BD 2012), 7 August 2012 Dr Abdullah Al Faruque ILDC 2980 (BD 2012)
United States – Measures Affecting the Cross-Border Supply of Gambling and Betting Services, Appellate Body Report, WT/DS285/ABR; ITL X (WTO 2005), 7 April 2005 Emilie Conway ITL 167 (WTO 2005)
Binational Panel Review Under Article 1904 Of The North American Free Trade Agreement Review of the Final Determination of Dumping Investigation on Imports of Chicken Legs and Thighs Coming from the United States, Ministry of Economy v Pilgrim’s Pride and ors, Final decision, Case MEX-USA-2012-1904-01; ITL 171 (NAFTA 2017), 21 April 2017 Roberto Soprano

ITL 171 (NAFTA 2017)

Trinidad Cement Limited Arawak Cement Limited (Claimants) and
The State of Barbados
(Defendant) and Rock Hard Cement Limited (Intervener), Ruling,  CCJ Application No. TTOJ2018/002; [2018] CCJ 1 (OJ); ITL 172 (CCJ 2018), 11 December 2018

Belen Olmos Giupponi ITL 172 (CCJ 2018)

European Communities and certain member States – Measures Affecting Large Civil Aircraft,
Recourse to Article 21.5 of the DSU by the United States, Appellate Body report, WT/DS316/AB/RW;
ITL173 (WTO 2018), 15 May 2018

Gustavo Ferreira Ribeiro ITL 173 (WTO 2016)