We use cookies to enhance your experience on our website. By continuing to use our website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. You can change your cookie settings at any time.
Find out more
Jump to Content
Jump to Main Navigation
User Account
Personal Profile
See all online law products
More
About
Subscriber Services
Guided Tour
FAQs
Help
Contact Us
Search
Browse all
Content type
Case reports
International court decisions
Domestic court decisions
European court cases
Arbitral cases
Commentary and analysis
Book content
Encyclopedia entries
Notes
International instruments and materials
Treaties
Supporting instruments
Institutional rules
Resolutions
Declarations
Model laws
Subject
Air law and law of outer space
Diplomacy and consular relations
European Union
History of international law
Human rights
Immunities
Individuals and non-state actors
International co-operation
International criminal law
International economic law
International environmental law
International humanitarian law
International law and international relations
International organizations
International procedural law
International responsibility
Law of the sea
Law of treaties
Relationship between international and domestic law
Settlement of disputes
Sources, foundations and principles of international law
Statehood, jurisdiction of states, organs of states
Territory
Theory of international law
Use of force, war, peace and neutrality
Author
Geographic region
Geographic Regions
Africa
Americas
Asia
Europe
Oceania
Organization
Organizations/Institutions
American Organizations/Institutions
African Organizations/Institutions
Asian Organizations/Institutions
European Organizations/Institutions
International Organizations/Institutions
Middle Eastern Organizations/Institutions
Pacific Rim Organizations/Institutions
My Content
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Entry
My Searches
(0)
Recently viewed
(0)
Save Search
Print
Save
Cite
Email this content
Share Link
Copy this link, or click below to email it to a friend
Email this content
or copy the link directly:
https://opil.ouplaw.com/abstract/10.1093/law/9780199658022.001.0001/law-9780199658022-miscMatter-13
The link was not copied. Your current browser may not support copying via this button.
Link copied successfully
Copy link
Sign in
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Username
Please enter your Username
Password
Please enter your Password
Forgot password?
Don't have an account?
Sign in via your Institution
You could not be signed in, please check and try again.
Sign in with your library card
Please enter your library card number
View translated passages only
Oxford Law Citator
Contents
Expand All
Collapse All
Preliminary Material
Foreword
Foreword
Foreword
Editors’ Preface
Notes on Contributors
Disclaimer
Contents
Table of Acronyms
Table of Frequently Cited Authorities
Main Text
Introduction
Preliminary Material
1 Background to and Purpose of the Study
1.1 International Criminal Justice: The Status Quo and Future Outlook
1.2 The Question of an International Criminal Procedure: A Branch of Law and a Discipline
1.3 The Project’s Objectives
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
1.4 Limitations
2 Approach and Methodology
2.1 Defining International Criminal Procedure and Coverage of Jurisdictions
2.2 Principal Object: Principles and General Rules
2.3 Mapping the Field and Division into Working Groups
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
(vii)
(viii)
(ix)
(x)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
(10)
(11)
2.4 Choice and Use of the Evaluative Framework
2.5 Standard-Identification Algorithm
(1)
(2)
(3)
2.6 Conclusions and Recommendations: Attribution and Authority
3 Structure and Scope of the Book
3.1 Standard Chapter Layout
3.2 Structure of the Book
3.3 Period Covered
1 General Framework of International Criminal Procedure
Preliminary Material
1 Introduction [Salvatore Zappalà]
1.1 ‘General Framework’: Meaning and Implications
1.2 Overview
2 Comparative Models and the Enduring Relevance Of The Accusatorial—Inquisitorial Dichotomy [Salvatore Zappalà]
2.1 Introduction
2.2 The Evolution of Procedural Systems In a Nutshell
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY and ICTR
iii ICC
iv Hybrid or mixed tribunals
2.3 Conclusion
3 Goals Of International Criminal Justice and International Criminal Procedure [Jens David Ohlin]
3.1 Introductory Remarks
3.2 Objectives and Functions of International Criminal Law
i Restoring international peace and security
ii Strengthening international humanitarian law protections
iii Punishing perpetrators of international crimes
iv Creating a historical record of atrocities
3.3 Objectives of International Criminal Procedure and Their Relationship to the Objectives and Functions of International Criminal Law
i Admission of relevant evidence for guilt
ii Historical truth-finding
iii Protecting due process rights
iv Structured victim participation
v Standard setting
vi Background goals
3.4 The Intrinsic Value of International Criminal Procedure
4 The Sources Of International Criminal Procedure [Frédéric Mégret]
4.1 Introductory Remarks
4.2 Historical Process
4.3 Statutes and Rules of Procedure and Evidence
4.4 Secondary Status of Some Principal Sources of International Law
4.5 Significance of General Principles of Law
4.6 Precedents
4.7 Relevant Domestic Law
4.8 Conclusion
5 The Human Rights Dimension of International Criminal Procedure [Lorenzo Gradoni]
5.1 Introductory Remarks
5.2 Human Rights Clauses In Foundational Instruments of International Criminal Courts and Tribunals
5.3 The Obligation to Respect Human Rights and Its Position In the Legal Systems of International Criminal Courts and Tribunals
i Sources of obligation
ii The lex superior status of human rights obligations
5.4 Defining the Content of Human Rights Standards
5.5 Functions of Human Rights Standards
5.6 Conclusion
6 Cooperation From States and Other Entities [Astrid Reisinger–Coracini]
6.1 An Essential Feature of International Criminal Procedure
6.2 Cooperation Schemes
6.3 Obligations
i States parties
a Statutory duty to cooperate fully in the investigation and prosecution
b Other duties
ii States not party
iii International organizations
iv Individuals
6.4 Coping With Non-Compliance
i Judicial responses
a Decisions as to non-cooperation
b Proceedings in absentia
c Contempt of court
ii Political responses
6.5 Securing Human Rights In The Process Of Obtaining Cooperation
i Cooperation regimes and internationally recognized human rights
ii Remedies for violations
6.6 Conclusion
7 Jurisdictional Arrangements And International Criminal Procedure [Sarah M.H. Nouwen and Dustin A. Lewis]
7.1 Introduction
7.2 Jurisdictional Arrangements as a Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, SCSL, and STL
a Concurrent jurisdiction
b Primacy
c Conditional primacy
d Ne bis in idem
e Referrals
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
iii ICC
a Concurrent jurisdiction
b Jurisdictional hierarchy
c Ne bis in idem
d ‘Deferring’ cases to national jurisdictions
iv Other non-exclusively domestic courts and tribunals
7.3 Conclusion: Impact of Jurisdictional Arrangements On National Criminal Procedure
8 Summary and Conclusion [Salvatore Zappalà]
2 Initiation of Investigations and Selection of Cases
Preliminary Material
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY and ICTR
iii SCSL
iv ICC
v SPSC
vi ECCC
vii STL
viii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
1
2
3
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Equality
b Non-discrimination
c Impartiality
d Independence
e Sufficiency of evidence
ii Rules
D Recommendations
3 Investigation, Coercive Measures, Arrest, and Surrender
Preliminary Material
1 Introductory Remarks
2 Investigation Phase: Delineation and Scope
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Definition
b Delineation of the investigation phase
c Collection of evidence
d Objectivity
e Other duties relevant to the conduct of the investigation
iii ICC
a Preliminary examination
b Collection of evidence
b.1 Prosecutor
b.2 Defence
b.3 Chambers
b.4 Legal representatives of victims
c Objectivity
d Duties and powers of the prosecutor
e Duty of due diligence
f Duration of investigations
iv SPSC
a Definition
b Delineation
c Collection of evidence
d Objectivity
e Duty of due diligence
v ECCC
a Definition
b Delineation
c Collection of evidence
d Objectivity
e Other duties relevant to the conduct of the investigation
vi STL
a Definition
b Delineation
c Collection of evidence
d Objectivity
e Duty of due diligence
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Structure of the investigation phase
b Role of the prosecutor
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3 Collection Of Evidence
3.1 Non-Coercive Investigative Acts
3.1.1 Interrogation of Suspects and Accused Persons
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Applicable procedural regime
a.1 Status of the interviewee
a.2 Status of the interviewer
b Power and procedural safeguards
b.1 The power of the prosecutor to question suspects and accused persons
b.2 Right to assistance by counsel during interrogation
b.3 Right to remain silent
b.4 Right to be informed of the charges or allegations
b.5 Right to the free assistance of an interpreter
b.6 Conduct of the questioning
iii ICC
a Applicable procedural regime
a.1 Status of the interviewee
a.2 Status of the interviewer
b Power and procedural safeguards
b.1 Prosecutorial power
b.2 Right to assistance by counsel during interrogation
b.3 Right to remain silent
b.4 Right to be informed of the charges or allegations
b.5 Right to the free assistance of an interpreter
b.6 Conduct of the questioning
iv SPSC
a Power to question suspects and accused persons
b Procedural safeguards
v ECCC
a Power to question suspects and charged persons
b Conduct of questioning
c Procedural safeguards
vi STL
a Power to question suspects and accused persons
b Conduct of questioning
c Procedural safeguards
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a Right to assistance by counsel during interrogation
b Right to remain silent
c Right to be informed of the charges or allegations
d Right to the free assistance of an interpreter
e Prohibition of torture and inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.2 Questioning of Witnesses
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Applicable procedural regime
b Admission of out-of-court witness statements at trial
c Power to interview witness
d The power to compel witnesses to be interviewed
e Procedural norms applying to the questioning of witnesses
iii ICC
a Applicable procedural regime
b Admission of out-of-court witness statements at trial
c Power to interview witnesses
d The power to compel witnesses to be interviewed
e Procedural norms applying to the questioning of witnesses
e.1 Guarantee against self-incrimination
e.2 Other procedural safeguards
f Conduct of the interview
iv SPSC
a Power to interview witnesses
b Conduct of witness interviews
v ECCC
a Power to interview witnesses
b The power to compel witnesses to be interviewed
c Conduct of the interview
d Procedural norms applying to the questioning of witnesses
vi STL
a Power to question witnesses
b Admissibility of out-of-court statements
c Procedural norms on the conduct of the questioning of witnesses
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights
a The privilege against self-incrimination for witnesses
b Right to examine witnesses
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.2 Non-Custodial Coercive Investigative Acts
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Direct enforcement v. requests for judicial assistance
b Formal and material conditions for the use of coercive measures
b.1 Judicial authorization
b.2 Principle of proportionality
b.3 Necessity (subsidiarity)—specificity
b.4 Threshold for coercive action
c Search and seizure operations
d Tracing, freezing, and seizure of property, proceeds, or instrumentalities of the crime
e Interception of communications
f Examinations of body and mind
iii ICC
a Direct enforcement v. requests for judicial assistance
b Formal and material conditions for the use of coercive measures
b.1 Judicial authorization
b.2 Principle of proportionality
b.3 Necessity—specificity
b.4 General threshold for the use of coercive measures
c Search and seizure operations
d Identification, tracing, and seizure of property, proceedings, assets, and instrumentalities of crimes
e Interception of communications
f Examinations of body and mind
iv SPSC
a Formal and material conditions
b Specific coercive acts
v ECCC
a Formal and material conditions
b Specific coercive acts
vi STL
a Formal and material conditions
b Specific coercive acts
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a Requirement of judicial authorization
b Requirement of proportionality
c Privilege against self-incrimination
d Inhuman and degrading treatment
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Requirement of judicial authorization
b General threshold
c Proportionality
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
4 Restriction and Deprivation of Liberty
4.1 Arrest
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
4.2 Detention on Remand and Provisional Release
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a Right to personal liberty
b Right not to be detained for an unreasonable period of time
c Right to be promptly informed of the reasons for arrest
d Right to be promptly brought before a judge or ‘officer’
e Right to challenge the lawfulness of detention
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Arrests without a warrant
b Bail and other alternatives to detention
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
a General
b Issuance of arrest warrant
c Execution of arrest warrant
d Detention on remand
5 Remedies
5.1 General Framework
A Law and Practice in International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
5.2 Specific Remedies In The Context Of Unlawful Arrest, Surrender, And Detention
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Stays of proceedings
b Financial compensation
c Sentence reduction
d Other remedies
iii ICC
a Stays of proceedings
b Financial compensation
c Sentence reduction
d Other remedies
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
a Stays of proceedings
b Financial compensation
c Sentence reduction
d Other remedies
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a ICCPR and ECHR
b ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
c ICC
d Other international(ized) criminal tribunals
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Stays of proceedings
b Financial compensation
c Sentence reduction
d Other remedies
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
4 Charges
Preliminary Material
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Bringing charges
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Charging practice
b Form of the indictment
c Cumulative charges
iii ICC
a Charging practice
b Form of the document containing the charges
c Cumulative charges
iv SPSC
v ECCC
a Form of the indictment
b Cumulative charges
vi STLa. Form of the indicment
b Cumulative charges
A.2 Confirming charges
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
a Timing of the confirmation procedure and the responsible Chamber
b Disclosure regime prior to the confirmation hearing
c Filing the document containing the charges
d Confirmation hearing: modalities
e Standard for confirming charges
f Powers of the Pre-Trial Chamber: can it re-qualify charges?
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.3 Amending, adding, and withdrawing charges
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Amending charges
b Bringing new charges
c Reducing the scope of the indictment
d Withdrawal of the indictment
e Curing a defective indictment
iii ICC
a Amending charges
b Bringing new charges
c Withdrawing charges
d Curing defective charges
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.4 Deciding on charges
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a ‘Half-way’ determinations
b Final determination at trial
c The iura novit curia principle
d Cumulative convictions
iii ICC
a ‘Half-way’ determinations
b Final determination at trial
c The iura novit curia principle
1
2
3
(a)
(b)
d Cumulative convictions
iv SPSC
a Final determination at trial
v ECCC
a Final determination at trial
b Cumulative convictions
vi STL
a ‘Half-way’ determinations
b Final determination at trial
c Cumulative convictions
A.5 Lis pendens, res judicata , and ne bis in idem
i Introduction
ii IMT and IMTFE
iii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Ne bis in idem
b Lis pendens
c Res judicata
iv ICC
a Ne bis in idem
b Lis pendens
c Res judicata
v SPSC
vi ECCC
vii STL
A.6 Synthesis
i Bringing charges
a Who brings the charges?
b Charging practice
c Form of the indictment
d Cumulative charging
ii Confirming charges
a Type of confirmation procedure
b Purposes of judicial review
c Amendment of charges by the Pre-Trial Chamber proprio motu
iii Amending, adding, and withdrawing charges
iv Deciding on charges
a ‘No case to answer’ proceedings
b Final determination at trial and the iura novit curia principle
c Cumulative convictions
v Lis pendens, res judicata, and ne bis in idem
a Ne bis in idem
b Lis pendens
c Res judicata
B Evaluation
B.1 Bringing charges—confirming charges—amending, adding, and withdrawing charges—deciding on charges
i Introduction
ii Human rights law
a Right to be presumed innocent and right to an impartial tribunal
b Right to be informed of the charges
c Equality of arms and the right to an adversarial hearing
d Right to trial within a reasonable time
e Iura novit curia principle
iii Comparative criminal procedure
a General issues
b Bringing charges
c Confirming charges
d Amending, adding, and withdrawing charges
e Deciding charges
iv Goals of international criminal justice
v Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
B.2 Lis pendens, res judicata , and ne bis in idem
i Human rights law
a Ne bis in idem
b Lis pendens and res judicata
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Ne bis in idem
b Lis pendens
c Res judicata
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
B.3 Synthesis
i Bringing charges—confirming charges—amending, adding, and withdrawing charges—deciding on charges
ii Lis pendens, res judicata , and ne bis in idem
a Ne bis in idem
b Lis pendens
C General Rules and Principles
C.1 Bringing charges
i Principles
a Form and content of the indictment
ii General rules
a Cumulative charges
C.2 Confirming charges
i Principles
a Judicial review of the charges and committal for trial
b Application of iura novit curia principle when confirming the charges
c Process of confirming charges
ii General rules
C.3 Amending, adding, and withdrawing charges
i Principles
a Amendment of charges
b Withdrawal of charges
ii General rules
C.4 Deciding on charges
i Principles
a Halfway determinations or ‘no case to answer’ proceedings
b Iura novit curia and final determination on the charges
c Cumulative convictions
ii General rules
a Half-way determinations or ‘no case to answer’ proceedings
b Iura novit curia and final determination on the charges
c Cumulative convictions
C.5 Lis pendens, res judicata , and ne bis in idem
i Principles
a Horizontal (internal) ne bis in idem
b Vertical downwards ne bis in idem vis-à-vis national and other international courts
c Vertical upwards ne bis in idem vis-à-vis national and other international courts
d Lis pendens
e Res judicata
ii General rules
D Recommendations
D.1 Bringing charges
D.2 Confirming charges
i Process of confirming charges
ii Application of the iura novit curia principle (pre-trial)
D.3 Amending, adding, and withdrawing charges
D.4 Deciding on charges
i ‘No case to answer’ proceedings
ii Application of the iura novit curia principle at trial
iii Cumulative convictions
D.5 Lis pendens, res judicata , and ne bis in idem
i Ordinary crime exception
ii Principle of deduction in subsequent trials
iii Decisions constituting res judicata
5 Trial Process
Preliminary Material
1 Introductory Remarks
2 Conduct of Trial Proceedings
2.1 General Issues
2.1.1 Joinder and Severance [S. Linton]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
a Regulation
a.1 IMT
a.2 IMTFE
b Cases
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a ICTY Regulation
b ICTY Cases
b.1 Joinder
‘The same transaction’
Common scheme, strategy, or plan
Linkages, inherent connection between indictments
Nexus between the accused
The role of the accused
Other considerations laid down in the Statute and RPE—protection of the rights of the accused
Other considerations not expressly laid down in the Statute or RPE
‘Conflicts of interest that might cause serious prejudice to the accused’
‘The interests of justice’
Judicial economy
Minimizing hardship to witnesses and increasing the likelihood that they will be able to give evidence
Ensuring the consistency of findings
b.2 Severance
‘Conflict of interests that might cause serious prejudice to an accused’
‘the interests of justice’
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
c ICTR Regulation
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(1)
(2)
d ICTR Cases
d.1 Joinder
‘the same transaction’
(1)
(2)
(3)
Other considerations laid down in the Statute and RPE—protection of the rights of the accused
Other considerations not expressly laid down in Rule 48 or in the Statute or RPE
‘conflicts of interest’
‘the interests of justice’
d.2 Severance
‘conflict of interests that might cause serious prejudice to an accused’
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
‘the interests of justice’
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
e SCSL Regulation
f SCSL cases
f.1 Joinder
f.2 Severance
iii ICC
a ICC Regulation
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
b ICC cases
(1)
(2)
(3)
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
a STL Regulation
(A)
(B)
b STL Cases
vii Synthesis
a Joinder
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
b Severance
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Expedience, coherence, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Joinder
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
b Severance
ii General rules
a Joinder
(1)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(2)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
b Severance
(1)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(2)
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
(e)
D Recommendations
2.1.2 Single and Bifurcated Trials [G. Acquaviva]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
D Recommendations
2.2 Structure of Contested Trial [S. Vasiliev]
2.2.1 Opening Statements
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Regulation
b Timing for the defence opening statement
c Statement of the accused (ICTY)
d Content and length; judicial control
iii ICC
a Regulation
b Statement by the accused
c Opening statements by the victims
d Order, contents, and length of opening statements
e Disclosure of opening statements
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Competent procedural actors
b Sequence/timing
c Length and content; judicial control
ii General rules
a Competent procedural actors
b Sequence/timing
c Length and content; judicial control
D Recommendations
2.2.2 Order of Presentation of Evidence
???
a
i
a
b
ii
a
b
iii
a
b
iv
a
b
v
a
b
vi
vii
a
b
b
i
ii
iii
iv
v
c
i
ii
d
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
a Order of presentation of evidence
b Order and modes of questioning witnesses
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Order of presentation of evidence
a.1 General features
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
a.2 Evidence for the prosecution and evidence for the defence
a.3 Prosecution evidence in rebuttal
a.4 Defence evidence in rejoinder
a.5 Evidence ordered by the Chamber
a.6 Information relevant to sentencing
a.7 Reopening of the case
b Order and modes of examination of witnesses
b.1 General features
b.2 Examination-in-chief
b.3 Cross-examination
b.4 Re-examination
b.5 Further cross-examination
b.6 Extra-sequential questioning by the judges
b.7 Specifics of examination in the multiple-defendant cases
iii ICC
a Order of presentation of evidence
a.1 Regulation
a.2 Practice
b Order and modes of examination of witnesses
b.1 Regulation
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
b.2 Sequence of questioning
b.3 Questioning by the party calling the witness (examination-in-chief)
b.4 Questioning by the party not calling the witness (cross-examination)
a
b
c
d
b.5 Additional questions by the party calling the witness (re-examination)
b.6 Final questioning by the defence
b.7 Questioning by the legal representatives of the victims
a)
b)
c)
d)
b.8 Judicial questioning
iv SPSC
a Order of presentation of evidence
b Order and modes of examination of witnesses
v ECCC
a Order of presentation of evidence
b Order and modes of examination of witnesses
vi STL
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
(v)
(vi)
vii Synthesis
a Order of presentation of evidence
b Order and modes of questioning witnesses
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Order of presentation of evidence
b Order and modes of examining witnesses
ii General rules
a Order of presentation of evidence
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
b Order and modes of examining witnesses
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
D Recommendations
2.2.3 Closing Arguments
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Competent actors
b Sequence
c Length and content; judicial control; final trial briefs
ii General rules
a Competent actors
b Sequence
c Length and content; judicial control; final trial briefs
D Recommendations
2.3 Structure of Uncontested Trial [N. Combs]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
D Recommendations
3 Participants/Actors at Trial: Residual Matters
3.1 Judicial Powers During Trial Proceedings
3.1.1 Fact-Finding Powers [N.Combs]
3.1.1.1 Power to Order Additional Evidence and to Call Witnesses Proprio Motu
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.1.2 Power to Question Witnesses During Trial
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.1.3 Power to Subpoena Witnesses
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY and ICTR
a Power to issue a subpoena
b Recipients of the subpoena
c Pre-trial and post-cross-examination interviews
d Tests for issuing a subpoena
e Enforcing a subpoena
iii SCSL
iv ICC
v SPSC
vi ECCC
vii STL
viii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.1.4 Power to Make On-site Visits
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal procedure
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.1.5 Power to Control (and Intervene in) the Examination of Witnesses
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY and ICTR
iii SCSL
iv ICC
i)
ii)
iii)
iv)
v)
v SPSC
vi ECCC
1
2
vii STL
viii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
(1)
(2)
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.2 Control over the Sequence of Case Presentation [N. Combs]
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
e
f
g
h
i
j
ii ICTY and ICTR
iii SCSL
(A)
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
iv ICC
v SPSC
vi ECCC
vii STL
viii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Principles
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.1.3 General Duty to Ensure the Integrity of the Proceedings [Y. McDermott]
Introductory Remarks
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Contempt
b False testimony
c Disruptive accused
iii ICC
a Contempt and false testimony
b Disruptive accused
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Interference with the administration of justice and false testimony
b Disruption of proceedings
ii General rules
a Contempt and false testimony
b Disruption of proceedings
D Recommendations
3.1.4 General Duty to Ensure the Right to a Fair and Expeditious Trial [Y. McDermott]
Introductory Remarks
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a General
b Judicial impartiality
i)
ii)
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
iii ICC
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
iv SPSC
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
v ECCC
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
vi STL
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
vii Synthesis
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
d Equality of arms
e Remedies
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Equality of arms
d Remedies
ii General rules
a General
b Judicial impartiality
c Trial without undue delay
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
d Remedies
D Recommendations
3.2 Witnesses: Protection and Testimony
3.2.1 Protective and Special Measures for Witnesses [G. Acquaviva and M. Heikkilä]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Protection vis-à-vis the public and media
i Introductory remarks
ii IMT and IMTFE
iii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iv ICC
v SPSC
vi ECCC
vii STL
viii Synthesis
A.2 Protection Vis-à-vis Other Participants in the Proceedings
i Introductory remarks
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.3 Special Support to Vulnerable Witnesses
i Introductory remarks
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv ECCC
v STL
vi Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
3.2.2 Regular Witness Testimony [Y. McDermott]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Live witness testimony
b Testimony via video- and audio-link
iii ICC
a Live witness testimony
(i)
(ii)
b Testimony via video- and audio-link
iv SPSC
a Live witness testimony
(a)
(b)
(c)
b Testimony via video-link
v ECCC
a Live witness testimony
b Testimony via video-link
vi STL
a Live witness testimony
b Testimony via video-link
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Live witness testimony
ii General rules
a Live witness testimony
b Testimony via video-link
D Recommendations
3.2.3 Testimony of Expert Witnesses, Journalists, ICRC, and UN staff [S. Linton]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
a Regulation
b Cases
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a ICTY Regulation
a.1 Expert witnesses
(A)
(B)
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(C)
a.2 ICRC
a.3 Journalists
a.4 UN officials and experts on mission
b ICTY cases
b.1 Expert witnesses
Standards for admission as an expert witness
Qualifications of the witness
Impartiality of the witness
Relevant specialized knowledge that may assist the Chamber in understanding the evidence
The limits to expert testimony
b.2 ICRC
b.3 Journalists
(1)
(2)
(3)
(1)
(2)
b.4 UN officials and experts on mission
Waiver of immunity by the Secretary-General
Conditions of testifying
Protection of confidential information
c ICTR Regulation
c.1 Expert witnesses
(A)
(B)
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(C)
c.2 ICRC
c.3 Journalists
c.4 UN officials and experts on mission
d ICTR cases
d.1 Expert witnesses
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Standards for admission as an expert witness
Qualifications of the witness
Impartiality of the witness
Relevant specialized knowledge that may assist the Chamber in understanding the evidence
The limits to expert testimony
d.2 Journalists
d.3 ICRC
d.4 UN Staff
Waiver of immunity is needed from the Secretary-General
Conditions of testifying
e SCSL Regulation
e.1 Expert witnesses
(A)
(B)
(i)
(ii)
(C)
e.2 ICRC
e.3 Journalists
e.4 UN officials and experts on mission
f SCSL cases
f.1 Expert witnesses
Standards for admission as an expert witness
Qualifications of the witness
Impartiality of the witness
Relevant specialized knowledge that may assist the Chamber in understanding the evidence
The limits to expert testimony
f.2 ICRC
f.3 Journalists
f.4 UN officials and experts on mission
iii ICC
a Regulation
a.1 Expert witnesses
1
2
3
4
5
a.2 ICRC
a.3 Journalists
a.4 UN officials and experts on mission
b Cases
b.1 Expert witnesses
b.2 ICRC
b.3 Journalists
b.4 UN officials and experts on mission
iv SPSC
a Regulation
a.1 Expert witness
a.2 Journalists
a.3 ICRC
a.4 UN officials and experts on mission
b Cases
b.1 Expert witnesses
b.2 Journalists
b.3 ICRC
b.4 UN officials and experts on mission
v ECCC
a Regulation
a.1 Expert witnesses
a.2 Journalists
a.3 ICRC
a.4 UN officials and experts on mission
b Cases
b.1 Expert witness
b.2 Journalists
b.3 ICRC
b.4 UN officials and experts on mission
vi STL
a Regulation
a.1 Expert witnesses
a.2 Journalists
a.3 ICRC
a.4 UN officials and experts on mission
b Cases
vii Synthesis
a Expert witnesses
b ICRC
c Journalists
(a)
(b)
(c)
(a)
(b)
d UN officials and experts on mission
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Expert witnesses
b ICRC
c Journalists
d UN officials and experts on mission
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Expert witnesses
b ICRC
1
2
a
b
c UN officials and experts on mission
1
2
3
ii General rules
a Expert witnesses
Admission as an expert witness
1
a
b
2
a
b
c
3
a
b
Limits to the testimony of experts
1
a
b
2
3
a
b
4
a
b
5
The expert’s report
1
2
3
4
D Recommendations
i Experts—guidelines
ii Journalists—principles and rules
a Principles
1
2
b Rules
1
a
b
c
1
a
b
2
a
b
c
d
1
a
b
iii Qualified privilege from compellability for humanitarian agencies—principles and rules
a
b
c
a Principles concerning humanitarian organizations and their staff
1
2
b Rules concerning material evidence acquired by humanitarian organizations and their staff
1
2
6 Appeals, Reviews, and Reconsideration
Preliminary Material
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Appeals against final judgments of acquittal, conviction, sentence, and reparation orders
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Right to appeal
b Grounds and standard of review on appeals against final judgments
b.1 Errors of law and procedural errors
b.2 Errors of fact
c Grounds and standard of review in appeals against sentence
d Judicial powers on appeal
e Appeals procedure
e.1 Notice of appeal
e.2 Preparations for hearing: appellate briefs and pre-appeal judge
e.3 Variation of grounds of appeal
e.4 Format of judgments and record on appeal
f Additional evidence on appeal
iii ICC
a Right to appeal and grounds of appeal
b Standard of review on appeals against final judgments and sentence
2
(a)
(b)
3
c Judicial powers on appeal
d Appeals procedure
d.1 Preparations for hearing, appellate briefs, and pre-appeal judge
d.2 Appeal hearing
d.3 Variation of grounds of appeal
d.4 Format of judgments and record on appeal
e Additional evidence on appeal
iv SPSC
a Right to appeal and grounds of appeal
b Standard of review
c Judicial powers on appeal
d Appeals procedure
e Additional evidence on appeal
v ECCC
a Right to appeal and grounds of appeal
b Standard of review on appeals
c Judicial powers on appeal
d Appeals procedure
e Additional evidence on appeal
vi STL
a Right to appeal
b Standard of review on appeals against final judgments
c Judicial powers on appeal
d Appeals procedure
e Additional evidence on appeal
A.2 Interlocutory Appeals
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Locus standi
b Decisions subject to and grounds of interlocutory appeal
c Standard of review
d Procedure on appeal
iii ICC
a Locus standi
b Decisions subject to and grounds of interlocutory appeals
c Standard of review and powers of the Appeals Chamber
d Procedure on appeal
iv SPSC
a Locus standi
b Decisions subject to and grounds of interlocutory appeals
c Standard of review and appellate powers
d Procedure on appeal
v ECCC
a Locus standi
b Decisions subject to and grounds of interlocutory appeal
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
h)
a)
b)
c)
d)
e)
f)
g)
h)
c Standard of review and appellate powers
d Procedure on appeal
vi STL
a Locus standi
b Decisions subject to and grounds of interlocutory appeal
c Standard of review and powers of the Appeals Chamber
d Procedure on appeal
A.3 Revision of final judgments
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Right to revision
b Standard
c Procedure
iii ICC
a Right to revision
b Standard
(a)
(i)
(ii)
(b)
(c)
c Procedure
iv SPSC
v ECCC
a)
i)
ii)
b)
c)
vi STL
A.4 Review of administrative decisions
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Jurisdiction to review administrative decisions
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
b President’s review of administrative decisions
c Jurisdiction of the Trial Chamber to intervene
iii ICC
a Jurisdiction to review administrative decisions
b Presidency review of administrative decisions
c Jurisdiction of the Trial Chamber to intervene
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.5 Reconsideration
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.6 Synthesis
i Appeals against final judgments of acquittal, conviction, sentence, and reparation orders
ii Interlocutory appeals
iii Revision of final judgments
iv Review of administrative decisions
v Reconsideration
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a Appeals against final judgments of acquittal, conviction, sentence, and reparation orders
1
2
b Interlocutory appeals
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
a Appeals against final judgments of acquittal, conviction, sentencing, and reparations
a.1 Right to appeal against final decision
a.2 Standard of review
a.3 Appellate powers
a.4 Extension of time limits
a.5 Grounds of appeal and variation
a.6 Additional evidence
b Interlocutory appeals
c Revision of final judgments
d Review of administrative decisions
e Reconsideration
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Appeals against final judgments of acquittal, conviction, sentence, and reparation orders
a.1 Right to appeal
a.2 Appellate grounds
a.3 Appellate powers
a.4 Appellate procedure: time limits and additional evidence
b Interlocutory appeals
c Revision/review of final judgments
d Review of administrative decisions
ii General rules
a Appeals against final judgments of acquittal, conviction, sentence, and reparation orders
a.1 Standard of review
a.2 Appellate procedure: variation of grounds
b Revision/review of final judgments
c Reconsideration
D Recommendations
i Need for greater expedition: enhanced use of pre-appeal judges and balanced interlocutory appeals
ii Additional evidence on appeal
iii First-instance decision-making by an Appeals Chamber
iv A new appellate jurisdiction?
7 Law of Evidence
Preliminary Material
1 Introductory Remarks
2 General Requirements for The Admission of Evidence [Mark Klamberg]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Applicability of national rules of evidence
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.2 Relevance and probative value
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.3 Reliability
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.4 Right to challenge the admissibility and discretion of the Trial Chamber
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.5 Exclusion of certain evidence
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.6 Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Relevance and probative value
ii General rules
a Applicability of national rules of evidence
b Exclusion of illegally or improperly obtained evidence
c Exclusion of evidence of the prior or subsequent sexual conduct of a victim or witness
D Recommendations
3 Admissibility Of Documentary Evidence [Fergal Gaynor]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
a Evidence of a witness in the form of a written statement, affidavit, or deposition
b Other forms of documentary evidence
c Admission from the bar table
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Evidence of a witness in the form of a written statement, a transcript of the witness’s prior evidence, or a deposition
a.1 Admitting a living witness’s evidence in writing without cross-examination
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(1)
(2)
(3)
a.2 Admitting a witness’s evidence in writing with cross-examination
a.3 Admitting a witness’s evidence in writing without cross-examination where the witness is dead or is, for good reason, unable to testify
a.4 Admitting a witness’s evidence in writing without cross-examination where the witness has been materially influenced by improper interference
a.5 The acts and conduct of the accused
a.6 Depositions
b Expert reports
c Admission of documentary evidence through witnesses
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
d General guidelines concerning the admission of documentary evidence directly to the Chamber: the bar table procedure
e Admission of ‘associated exhibits’ under Rule 92 ter ICTY RPE
f Admission of media reports, intercepts, forensic evidence, letters, and books
f.1 Media reports
f.2 Intercepts
f.3 Proof of death, torture, and rape
f.4 Letters
f.5 Lengthy documents and books
g Real evidence
h Admission of documents not listed on exhibit list
i Language of documentary evidence
j Documents not adopted by a witness
iii ICC
a Admission of witness statements, transcripts, and depositions
b Admission of documentary evidence through a witness
c Admission of documentary evidence from the bar table
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
1
2
3
4
iv SPSC
(a)
(b)
(c)
v ECCC
1
2
3
vi STL
a Admission of testimonial evidence
b Documentary evidence in terrorist trials; cellphone data
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Common law jurisdictions
b Civil law jurisdictions
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Categories of admissible documents
b Admission of documents through a witness
c Bar table procedure
d Admission of testimonial evidence in written form
e Admission of testimonial evidence in written form of a deceased witness
ii General rules
D Recommendations
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
(9)
4 Defence Access to the Prosecution Material [Vladimir Tochilovsky]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a General remarks
b Disclosure of the supporting material and statements of the accused
b.1 Supporting material
b.2 Prior statements of the accused
c Disclosure relating to prosecution witnesses
c.1 Disclosure of witness statements
c.2 Disclosure of the identity of witnesses
d Disclosure of exculpatory material
e Inspection of documents and objects material to the preparation of the defence
f Matters not subject to disclosure
f.1 Information provided on a confidential basis
f.2 Internal documents
f.3 Protection of other information
g Disclosure in electronic format
iii ICC
a General remarks
b Disclosure relating to prosecution witnesses
b.1 Disclosure of witness statements
b.2 Disclosure of the identity of witnesses
c Inspection of documents and objects material to the preparation of the defence
d Disclosure of exculpatory material
e Matters not subject to disclosure
e.1 Information provided on a confidential basis
e.2 Internal documents
e.3 Protection of other information
iv SPSC
a Disclosure of witness statements
b Disclosure of exculpatory material
c Inspection of documents and objects material to the preparation of the defence
d Matters not subject to disclosure
v ECCC
vi STL
a Disclosure of the supporting material and statements of the accused
b Disclosure of witness statements
c Disclosure of exculpatory material
d Inspection of documents and objects material to the preparation of the defence
e Matters not subject to disclosure
e.1 Information provided on a confidential basis
e.2 Internal documents
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a General remarks
b Restrictions in disclosure
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
5 Prosecution Access to the Defence Material [Mark Klamberg]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Statements, witnesses, defence of alibi, and special defences
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.2 Inspection
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.3 Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Principles and Rules of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
a Disclosure of list of witnesses
b Disclosure of the general nature of the accused’s defence
c Disclosure in relation to the defence of alibi
d Disclosure in relation to special defences such as diminished, or lack of, mental responsibility
D Recommendations
6 Judicial Notice and Agreed Facts [Fergal Gaynor]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Tribunals
i IMT and IMTFE
a Judicial notice of facts of common knowledge and of adjudicated facts
b Judicial notice of documentary evidence
c Agreed facts
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Judicial notice of facts of common knowledge and of adjudicated facts
a.1 Facts of common knowledge
a.2 Judicial notice of adjudicated facts
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
a.3 Difference between judicial notice of facts of common knowledge and that of adjudicated facts and documentary evidence
(1)
(2)
(3)
b Judicial notice of (the authenticity of) documentary evidence
c Agreed facts
iii ICC
a Judicial notice of facts of common knowledge, of adjudicated facts, and of the authenticity of documentary evidence
b Agreed facts
iv SPSC
a Judicial notice of facts of common knowledge, of adjudicated facts, and of the authenticity of documentary evidence
b Agreed facts
v ECCC
a Judicial notice of facts of common knowledge, of adjudicated facts, and of the authenticity of documentary evidence
b Agreed facts
vi STL
a Judicial notice of facts of common knowledge, of adjudicated facts, and of the authenticity of documentary evidence
b Agreed facts
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
(1)
(2)
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Principles and Rules of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
ii General rules
D Recommendations
(1)
(2)
(3)
7 Standard of Proof and Burden of Proof [Dov Jacobs]
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Pre-trial proceedings
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Initiation of an investigation
b Confirmation of an indictment
c Issuance of an arrest warrant
iii ICC
a Initiation of an investigation
b Issuance of an arrest warrant
c Confirmation of the charges
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.2 Judgment
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
A.3 Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles
i Principles
a Presumption of innocence
b Standard of proof for judgments
c Burden of proof
d In dubio pro reo
ii General rules
D Recommendations
8 Deliberation, Dissent, Judgment
Preliminary Material
Introduction
i Preliminary observations
ii Intuition and justification
iii Scope and overview of the chapter
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
iii ICC
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
iv SPSC
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
v ECCC
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
vi STL
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
vii Synthesis
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Character and appearance of final judgment
d Timing of final judgment
ii Comparative criminal procedure
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
c Character and appearance of final judgment
d Timing of final judgment
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and other relevant considerations
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
2
15
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
v Synthesis
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
C General Rules and Principles
i Principles
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
c Character and appearance of final judgment
d Timing of final judgment
ii General rules
a Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
b Bench composition and single-judge decisions
D Recommendations
a Privacy and secrecy of judicial deliberations
b Public nature of final judgment and interlocutory decisions
c Permissibility of majority or dissenting opinions
d Bench composition and single-judge decisions
e Character and appearance of final judgment
f Timing of final judgment
9 Defence Issues
Preliminary Material
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 Representation
A.1.1 Representation by counsel
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
1
2
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.1.2 Self-representation
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Milošević
b Šešelj
c Krajišnik
d Ngeze at the ICTR; Prlić et al. and Tolimir at the ICTY
e Standby Counsel at the ICTY
f Amicus curiae (ICTY)
g Norman (SCSL)
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.1.3 Mechanisms for vetting and ensuring the effective representation of the defendant
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
1
2
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.2 The defence
A.2.1 Institutional framing and remuneration
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.2.2 Defence counsel qualifications: minimum requirements for assigned counsel
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Common criteria
b Criteria for counsel assigned under the legal assistance scheme
iii ICC
a Common criteria
b Criteria for counsel assigned under the legal assistance scheme
iv SPSC
v ECCC
a Common criteria
b Criteria for counsel assigned under the legal assistance scheme
vi STL
a Common criteria
b Criteria for counsel assigned under the legal assistance scheme
vii Synthesis
a Common criteria
b Criteria for counsel assigned under the legal assistance scheme
A.2.3 Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: what does legal aid cover?
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.2.4 Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: calculating indigence and obtaining payment from accused
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.2.5 Legal aid for self-representing defendants
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.2.6 Defence counsel: professional regulation and discipline
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Organizational framework
b Professional discipline and professional obligations
c Contempt and other sanctioning mechanisms
iii ICC
a Organizational framework
b Professional discipline and professional obligations
c Offences against administration of justice and other sanctioning mechanisms
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
a Organizational framework
b Professional discipline and professional obligations
c Contempt, offences against the administration of justice, and other sanctioning mechanisms
B Evaluation
B.1 Representation
B.1.1 Representation by counsel
i Human rights law
(d)
(e)
5
6
7
8
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.1.2 Self-representation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.1.3 Mechanisms for vetting and ensuring the effective representation of the defendant
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.2 The defence
B.2.1 Institutional framing and remuneration
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.2.2 Defence counsel qualifications: minimum requirements for assigned counsel
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.2.3 Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: what does legal aid cover?
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.2.4 Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: calculating indigence and obtaining payment from accused
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.2.5 Legal aid for self-representing defendants
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
B.2.6 Defence counsel: professional regulation and discipline
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
(b)
(1)
(2)
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expedience, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Representation by counsel
b Self-representation
c Mechanisms for vetting and ensuring the effective representation of the defendant
d Institutional framing and remuneration of defence
e Defence counsel qualifications: minimum requirements for assigned counsel
f Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: what does legal aid cover?
g Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: calculating indigence and obtaining payment from accused
h Legal aid for self-representing defendants
i Professional regulation and discipline of counsel
j Specific professional obligations of counsel
k Contempt and other sanctioning mechanisms
ii General rules
a Self-representation
b Representation by counsel
c Mechanisms for vetting and ensuring the effective representation of the defendant
d Institutional framing and remuneration of defence
e Defence counsel qualifications: minimum requirements for assigned counsel
f Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: what does legal aid cover?
g Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: calculating indigence and obtaining payment from accused
h Legal aid for self-representing defendants
i Professional regulation and discipline of counsel
j Specific professional obligations of counsel
k Contempt and other sanctioning mechanisms
D Recommendations
a Self-representation
b Representation by counsel
c Mechanisms for vetting and ensuring the effective representation of the defendant
d Institutional framing and remuneration of defence
e Defence counsel qualifications: minimum requirements for assigned counsel
f Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: what does legal aid cover?
g Legal aid scheme for indigent accused: calculating indigency and obtaining payment from accused
h Legal aid for self-representing defendants
i Professional regulation and discipline of counsel
10 Victim Issues: Participation, Protection, Reparation, and Assistance
Preliminary Material
A
A.1
A.2
A.3
A.4
A.5
A.6
A.7
A.8
A.9
B
C
D
2
A
B
C
D
1 Victim Participation and Protection
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
A.1 The definition of the concept of a ‘victim’ and the status of victims giving evidence
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
A.2 Victim representation and participation on behalf of a victim
i ICC
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
A.3 Notifications to victims and/or their legal representatives
i ICC
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
A.4 Participation at the investigation pre-trial stage (no identified perpetrator)
i ICC
a Introduction
b Participation in proceedings relating to the initiation of investigations (Article 15(3))
c Participation in proceedings addressing jurisdiction and admissibility (Article 19(3))
d Participation at the investigation stage (Article 68(3))
e Right to initiate investigations and investigative measures, and to conduct investigations themselves
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
A.5 Participation at the pre-trial stage (with a case and a charged/indicted person)
i ICC
a Participation based on Article 68(3)
b Participation in proceedings addressing jurisdiction and admissibility (Article 19(3))
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
A.6 Participation at the trial stage
i ICC
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
A.7 Participation at the sentencing stage
i ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
ii ICC
iii SPSC
iv ECCC
v STL
vi Synthesis
A.8 Participation in appeals
i ICC
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
A.9 Protective measures for victim participants and civil parties
i ICC
ii SPSC
iii ECCC
iv STL
v Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles
i Principles
ii General rules
a Victim participation
b Modes and stages of participation
c Legal representation
d Protective measures
e Notifications
D Recommendations
2 Reparation and General Assistance to Victims
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
iii ICC
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles
i Principles
a Assistance and support
ii General rules
a Reparations
D Recommendations
11 Negotiated Justice
Preliminary Material
Introduction
A Law and Practice of International Criminal Procedure
i IMT and IMTFE
ii ICTY, ICTR, and SCSL
a Original version of the statutes
b Requirements for valid guilty pleas
(a)
(b)
(c)
b.1 Voluntariness
b.2 Knowledge
b.3 Lack of equivocation
b.4 Factual basis
c Rules pertaining to plea agreements
d Form and subject-matter of plea bargaining
e Consequences of guilty plea withdrawal and breach of plea agreement
f Roles of the parties, the court, and victims in plea bargaining
g Sentencing consequences
iii ICC
a Requirements for valid admissions of guilt
b Subject-matter of bargaining between the parties
c Roles of the parties, the court, and victims in plea bargaining
d Sentencing consequences
e Consequences of withdrawing an admission of guilt or breaching an agreement between the parties
iv SPSC
v ECCC
vi STL
vii Synthesis
B Evaluation
i Human rights law
ii Comparative criminal procedure
iii Goals of international criminal justice
a Truth-finding
b Promoting Peace and Reconciliation
c Conclusion
iv Coherence, expediency, and practical considerations
v Synthesis
C General Rules and Principles of International Criminal Procedure
i Principles
a Validity of admission of guilt
b Subject-matter and effect of plea agreements
ii General rules
a Validity of admission of guilt
(a)
(b)
(c)
b Acceptance of plea agreements by the court
c Procedural consequences of an invalid admission or agreement
D Recommendations
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)
Postscripts
[No Title]
Procedural Challenges Faced by International Criminal Tribunals and the Value of Codification
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Should National and International Justice be Subjected to the Same Evaluative Framework?
I
II
III
IV
V
Further Material
Bibliography
Table of Cases
Contents
International and hybrid courts, tribunals and treaty bodies
African Commission on Human and People’s Rights (ACommHPR)
European Court of Justice (ECJ) (in alphabetical order)
European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) (in alphabetical order)
European Commission on Human Rights (ECommHR)
Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia (ECCC)
Case No. 001 (Kaing Guek Eav, a.k.a. Duch)
Case No. 002 (Nuon Chea, Ieng Sary, Khieu Samphan and Ieng Thirith)
Cases No. 003 & 004
Human Rights Committee (HRC) (in alphabetical order)
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACommHR)
Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR)
International Arbitration Awards
International Criminal Court (ICC)
Disciplinary Board
Presidency
Situation in Côte d’Ivoire (ICC-02/11)
Laurent Gbagbo (ICC-02/11-01/11)
Situation in the Central African Republic (ICC-01/05)
Jean-Pierre Bemba Gombo (ICC-01/05-01/08)
Situation in Darfur, Sudan (ICC-02/05)
Ahmad Muhammad Harun and Ali Muhammad Ali Abd-Al-Rahman (ICC-02/05-01/07)
Omar Hassan Ahmad Al Bashir (ICC-02/05-01/09)
Bahar Idriss Abu Garda (ICC-02/05-02/09)
Abdallah Banda Abakaer Nourain and Saleh Mohammed Jerbo Jamus (ICC-02/05/03/09)
Situation in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (ICC-01/04)
Thomas Lubanga Dyilo (ICC-01/04-01/06)
Germain Katanga and Mathieu Ngudjolo Chui (ICC-01/04-01/07)
Bosco Ntaganda (ICC-01/04-02/06)
Callixte Mbarushimana (ICC-01/04-01/10)
Situation in the Republic of Kenya (ICC-01/09)
William Samoei Ruto, Henry Kiprono Kosgey and Joshua Arap Sang (ICC-01/09-01/11)
Francis Kirimi Muthaura, Uhuru Muigai Kenyatta and Mohammed Hussein Ali (ICC-01/09-02/11)
Situation in Libya (ICC-01/11)
Saif Al-Islam Gaddafi and Abdullah Al-Senussi (ICC-01/11-01/11)
Situation in Uganda (ICC-02/04)
Joseph Kony, Vincent Otti, Okot Odhiambo and Dominic Ongwen (ICC-02/04-01/05)
International Court of Justice (ICJ) [in alphabetic order]
International Criminal Tribunal for Rwanda (ICTR) [in alphabetic order]
Akayesu (ICTR-96-4)
Bagambiki, Imanishimwe, and Munyakazi (ICTR-97-36)
Bagaragaza (ICTR-2005-86)
Bagilishema (ICTR-95-1A)
Bagosora (ICTR-96-7)
Bagosora, Kabiligi, Ntabakuze, and Nsengiyumva (ICTR-98-41)
Barayagwiza (ICTR-97-19)
Bikindi (ICTR-2001-72)
Bisengimana (ICTR-2000-60-I)
Augustin Bizimungu, Ndindiliyimana, Nzuwonemeye, and Sagahutu (ICTR-00-56)
Casimir Bizimungu, Mugenzi, Bicamumpaka, and Mugiraneza (ICTR-99-50)
GAA (ICTR-07-90-R77)
Gacumbitsi (ICTR-2001-64)
Gatete (ICTR-2000-61)
Hategekimana (ICTR-00-55B)
Kambanda (ICTR-97-23)
Kajelijeli (ICTR-98-44A)
Kalimanzira (ICTR-05-88)
Kamuhanda (ICTR-99-54)
Kanyabashi (ICTR-96-15)
Kanyarukiga (ICTR-2002-78)
Karemera, Kabuga, Ngirumpatse, and Nzirorera (ICTR-98-44)
Karera (ICTR-01-74)
Kayishema (ICTR-2001-67)
Kayishema and Ruzindana (ICTR-95-1)
Kamuhanda (ICTR-99-54)
Mpambara (ICTR-01-65)
Mugenzi (ICTR-99-50)
Mugiraneza (ICTR-99-48)
Muhimana (ICTR-95-1B)
Munyakazi (ICTR-1997-36)
Musema (ICTR-96-13)
Muvunyi, Nizeyimana, and Hategekimana (ICTR-2000-55)
Nahimana (ICTR-96-11)
Nahimana and Barayagwiza (ICTR-99-55)
Nahimana, Ngeze, and Barayagwiza (ICTR-99-52)
Nchamihigo (ICTR-2001-63)
Ndayambaje, Kanyabashi, Nyiramasuhuko, Ntahobali, Nsabimana, and Nteziryayo (ICTR-96-8)
Ndindabahizi (ICTR-01-71)
Ngeze (ICTR-99-52)
Ngirabatware (ICTR-99-54)
Ngirumpatse (ICTR-97-44)
Niyitegeka (ICTR-96-14)
Nizeyimana (ICTR-00-55C)
Nsabimana and Nterziryayo (ICTR-97-29)
Nsengimana (ICTR-01-69)
Nsengiyumva (ICTR-96-12)
Nshogoza (ICTR-07-91)
Ntabakuze and Kabiligi (ICTR-97-34)
Ntagerura, Bagambiki, and Imanishimwe (ICTR-99-46)
E. Ntakirutimana and G. Ntakirutimana (ICTR-96-10 and ICTR-96-17)
Ntawukulilyayo (ICTR-05-82)
Nterziryayo (ICTR-97-29)
Ntuyahaga (ICTR-98-40)
Nyiramasuhuko and Ntahobali (ICTR-97-21)
Nyiramasuhuko, Ntahobali, Nsabimana, Nteziryayo, Kanyabashi, and Ndayambaje (ICTR-98-42)
Nzabirinda (ICTR-2001-77)
Nzabonimana (ICTR-98-44D)
Radio Television Libre des Mille Collines sarl (ICTR-96-6-D)
Renzaho (ICTR-97-31)
Ruggiu (ICTR-97-32)
Rukundo (ICTR-2001-70)
Rutaganda (ICTR-96-3)
Rwamakuba (ICTR-98-44C)
Sagahutu (ICTR-00-56)
Semanza (ICTR-97-20)
Serushago (ICTR 98-39)
Seromba (ICTR-2001-66)
Simba (ICTR-01-76-1)
Uwinkindi (ICTR-2001-75-R11bis)
Zigiranyirazo (ICTR-2001-73)
International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY)
Ademi (IT-06-46)
Ademi and Norać (IT-04-78)
Aleksovski (IT-95-14/1-A)
Babić (IT-03-72)
Banović
Beara (IT-02-58)
Blagojević and Jokić (IT-02-60)
Beqaj (IT-03-66-R77)
Blaškić (IT-95-14)
Boškoski and Tarčulovski (IT-04-82)
Bralo (IT-95-17)
Brđanin and Talić (IT-99-36)
Čermak and Markač (IT-03-73)
Češić (IT-95-10/1)
Delalić, Mucić, Hazim Delić, and Landžo (IT-96-21)
Rasim Delić (IT-04-83)
Deronjić (IT-02-61)
Djukić (IT-96-20)
Ðorđević (IT-05-87)
Erdemović (IT-96-22)
Furundžija (IT-95-17/1)
Fuštar, Banović and Knežević (IT-95-8/1)
Galić (IT-98-29)
Gotovina (IT-01-45)
Gotovina, Čermak, and Markač (IT-06-90)
Hadžihasanović, Alagić, and Kubura (IT-01-47)
Halilović (IT-01-48)
Haradinaj, Balaj, and Brahimaj (IT-04-84)
Haraqija and Morina (IT-04-84-R77.4-A)
Hartmann (IT-02-54)
Haxhiu (IT-04-84-R77.5)
In re: Republic of Macedonia (IT-02-55-MISC.6)
Janković (IT-96-23/2)
Jelisić (IT-95-10)
Miodrag Jokić (IT-01-42/1)
Dragan Jokić (IT-05-88-R77.1)
Jović (IT-95-14/2-R77)
Kabashi (IT-04-84-R77.1)
Karadžić (IT-95-5/18)
Karadžić and Mladić (IT-95-5)
Kolundžija (IT-95-8)
Kordić, Blaškić, Čerkez, Šantić, Skopljak, and Aleksovski (IT-95-14)
Kordić and Čerkez (IT-95-14/2)
Kovačević (IT-97-24)
Krajišnik (IT-00-39)
Krajišnik and Plavšić (IT-00-39 and 40/1)
Krnojelac (IT-97-25)
Krstić (IT-98-33)
Kunarac, Kovač, and Vuković (IT-96-23 and 23/1)
Zoran Kupreškić, Mirjan Kupreškić, Vlado Kupreškić, Drago Josipović, Dragan Papić, and Vladimir Šantić (IT-95-16)
Kvočka, Kos, Radić, Zigić, and Prcać (IT-98-30/1)
Limaj, Musliu, and Bala (IT-03-66)
Ljubičić (IT-00-41)
S. Lukić and M. Lukić (IT-98-32/1)
Marijačić and Rebić (IT-95-14-R77.2)
Margetić (IT-95-14-R77.6)
Martić (IT-95-11)
Mejakić, Gruban and Knežević (IT-95-4)
Dragomir Milošević (IT-98-29/1)
Slobodan Milošević (IT-99-37, IT-01-50 and IT-01-51; IT-02-54)
S. Milošević, Milutinović, Šainović, Ojdanić, and Stojilković (IT-99-37)
Milutinović, Šainović, Ojdanić, Pavković, Lazarević, and Lukić (IT-05-87)
Mladić (IT-95-5)
Mrđa (IT-02-59)
Mrkšić, Radić, and Šlivančanin (IT-95-13/1)
Mrkšić, Radić, Šljivančanin, and Dokmanović (IT-95-13a)
Naletilić and Martinović (IT-98-34)
Dragan Nikolić (IT-94-2)
Momir Nikolić (IT-02-60/1)
Obrenović (IT-02-60/2)
Orić (IT-03-68-T)
Pandurević and Trbić (IT-05-86)
Pavković, Lazarević, Đordević, and Lukić (IT-03-70)
Perišić (IT-04-81)
L. Petković (IT-03-67-R77.1)
V Popović, Beara, Nikolić, Borovčanin, Tolimir, Miletić, Gvero, Pandurević, and Trbić (IT-02-57, IT-02-58, IT-02-63, IT-02-64, IT-04-80 and IT-05-86)
Prlić, Stojić, Praljak, Petković, Ćorić, and Pušić (IT-04-74)
Radić and Žigić
Rajić (IT-95-12-R61)
Rašević (IT-97-25)
Rašević and Todović (IT-97-25/1)
Šainović and Ojdanić (IT-99-37)
Šainović, Ojdanić, Pavković, Lazarević, and Lukić (IT-05-87)
Šešelj (IT-03-67)
Sikirica, Došen, and Kolundžija (IT-95-8)
B Simić, M. Simić, M. Tadić, Todorović, and Zarić (IT-95-9)
Šljivančanin (IT-95-13)
Stakić (IT-97-24)
Stanišić and Simatović (IT-03-69)
Stanišić and Župljanin (IT-08-91 and IT-95-5/l8)
Stanković (IT-96-23-2)
Strugar (IT-01-42)
D Tadić (IT-94-1)
Todorović (IT-95-9/1)
Tolimir (IT-05-88)
Tolimir, Miletić, and Gvero (IT-04-80)
Vasiljević (IT-98-32)
Zelenović (IT-96-23/2)
Žigić (IT-98-30)
Župljanin (IT-99-36/2)
International Military Tribunal (IMT)
International Military Tribunal for Far East (IMTFE)
Special Court for Sierra Leone (SCSL) (in alphabetic order)
Alex Tamba Brima, Brima Bazzy Kamara, and Santigie Borbor Kanu (AFRC, SCSL-04-16 etc.)
Sam Hinga Norman, Moinina Fofana, and Allieu Kondewa (CDF, SCSL-04-14, etc.)
Issa Hassan Sesay, Morris Kallon, Augustine Gbao (RUF, SCSL-04-15 etc.)
Charles Ghankay Taylor (SCSL-03-1)
Samura, Brima, Jalloh, A. Kamara, E. Kamara (SCSL-05-01)
Williams and Yillah
Special Panels for Serious Crimes, Dili District Court (SPSC)
Rudolfo Alves Correia
Amati and Matos
Sisto Barros, Cesar Mendonca, and Josep Nahak
Jose Cardoso Ferreira
Mendes Correia
Albilio Mendez Correira
Agustinho da Costa
Damião da Costa Nunes
João Franca da Silva, Sabino Gouveia Leite, Jose Cardoso Ferreira (‘Lolotoe’)
Lino de Carvalho
Paulino de Jesus
Augusto dos Santos
Carlos Ena
Umbertus Ena and Carlos Ena
Fernandez
Joseph Leki
Gaspar Leite (a.k.a. Leki)
Joni Marques, Manuel Da Costa, João Da Costa, Paulo Da Costa, Amélio Da Costa, Hilário Da Silva, Gonsalo Dos Santos, Alarico Fernandes, Mautersa Monis, and Gilberto Fernandes (‘Los Palos’)
Miguel Mau
Rusdin Maubere
Josep Nahak
Francisco Pedro
Perreira
Dos Santos Laku
Benjamin Sarmento
Benjamin Sarmento, Romeiro Tilman, Joao Sarmento, and Domingas Mendonca
João Sarmento
Fransisco Soares
Salvador Soares
Carlos Soares Carmona
Jose Valente
Wiranto et al.
Special Tribunal for Lebanon (STL)
Ayyash, Badreddine, Oneissi, and Sabra (STL-11-01)
In the Matter El Sayed
National courts
Australia
Belgium
Canada
France
Germany
Republic of Ireland
Israel
Italy
Malawi
The Netherlands
New Zealand
Singapore
South Africa
Spain
Switzerland
United Kingdom
Commonwealth (Privy Council)
England and Wales
United States of America
Table of Instruments
Contents
International treaties, conventions, and agreements
Resolutions, reports and regulations of (international) organizations
Assembly of the African Union
Assembly of States Parties (ICC)
Association of Defence Counsel Practising Before the ICTY
Control Council and Coordinating Committee of the Allied Control Authority
Council of Europe
ECCC
European Union
Human Rights Committee
IMT
International Association of Judges
International Bar Association
ICC
International Commission of Inquiry on Darfur
International Court of Justice (ICJ)
ICTR
ICTY
SCSL
STL
United Nations Commission on Human Rights
United Nations Economic and Social Council
United Nations General Assembly
United Nations Human Rights Committee
United Nations International Independent Investigation Commission
United Nations International Law Commission
United Nations Interim Administration Mission in Kosovo (UNMIK)
United Nations ICC Preparatory Committee, Diplomatic Conference of Plenipotentiaries, Preparatory Commission, Review Conference
United Nations Office for Drugs and Crime (UNODC)
United Nations Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights
United Nations Secretary-General
United Nations Security Council
United Nations Transitional Administration in East Timor (UNTAET)
Official statements, records, letters, and reports
ECCC
ICC
ICTR
ICTY
United Nations Office of International Oversight Services
United Nations Secretary-General
United Nations Security Council
National legislation, instruments, and reports (countries in alphabetic order)
Albania
Algeria
Argentina
Australia
Belgium
Bosnia and Herzegovina
Brazil
Bulgaria
Cambodia
Canada
China
Croatia
Denmark
East Timor
Egypt
Estonia
Finland
France
Germany
Greece
Hong Kong
Indonesia
India
Iraq
Israel
Italy
Japan
Kenya
Mexico
Netherlands
Norway
New Zealand
Poland
Portugal
Republic of Ireland
Russian Federation
Rwanda
Singapore
South Africa
Spain
Sweden
Switzerland
United Kingdom
England and Wales
Scotland
United States of America
Soft law (in chronological order)
Index
Sign up for alerts
Table of Cases
Edited By: Göran Sluiter, Håkan Friman, Suzannah Linton, Sergey Vasiliev, Salvatore Zappalà
From:
International Criminal Procedure: Principles and Rules
Edited By: Göran Sluiter, Håkan Friman, Suzannah Linton, Sergey Vasiliev, Salvatore Zappalà
Content type:
Book content
Product:
Oxford Scholarly Authorities on International Law [OSAIL]
Published in print:
21 March 2013
ISBN:
9780199658022
Prev
|
Next
[3.235.60.197]
3.235.60.197