Oxford Reports on International Law in Domestic Courts
Oxford Reports on International Law in Domestic Courts (ILDC) covers international law as applied in the domestic courts of around 70 jurisdictions. The geographical scope is intended to be as broad as possible; ILDC currently reports on countries from every continent in the world and continues to add new reporters and new jurisdictions.
The policy for ILDC has been to focus first on relevant cases from 2000 to the present for each jurisdiction, and then to work back through decisions of earlier years to increase the size of the archive. Occasionally, ILDC reports on much earlier cases if they are very important for the development of international law jurisprudence in a particular jurisdiction.
ILDC policy is to cover case law not only from states but also from certain territorial entities that are not generally classified as states. This is done in recognition of the fact that judicial decisions of such entities can be of interest to international lawyers, as recognized by the International Court of Justice and the European Court of Human Rights, amongst others. Publication of judicial decisions from such territorial entities does not reflect an opinion as to whether these entities should or should not be classified as states.
Case Selection Criteria
Cases are selected for inclusion in ILDC according to two broad criteria:
- Decisions which are relevant to the identification and interpretation of rules of international law, specifically
- Cases which are expected to be cited in international courts, the domestic courts of other jurisdictions, or in scholarly work, as authority for a particular point of international law.
- Cases which point to the development of new (interpretations of) international legal principles, or confirm well-established rules of international law.
- Cases which address a point of international law that is controversial or may be changing.
- Decisions which are relevant to the reception and application of international law by states in their national legal orders, including:
- Cases which are of particular importance for the way in which international law is applied in a particular country, such as new approaches to the interpretation of national law in the light of international law or new approaches to effectuating judgments of international courts, or
- Cases in which the method of reception is of interest in a comparative perspective because it differs from what is done in other states and/or because it may be an example that could be followed in other jurisdictions.
Citations listed in ILDC reports
Note that ILDC reports do not include lists of citations to domestic instruments and legislation mentioned in the decision, as such references generally have only a minor relevance to the international law issues involved. Further, only key domestic cases will be listed, as focusing too much on domestic case law is a distraction for the international law researcher.
Full citation information (i.e. including all domestic citations) for each reported case on ILDC will be made available in the Oxford Law Citator, once enhancement is completed (following publication of the case report).
EDITORS IN CHIEF
André Nollkaemper is Professor of Public International Law and Director of the Amsterdam Center for International Law at the faculty of Law of the Universiteit van Amsterdam.
Previous academic positions include Fellow of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Erasmus University Rotterdam, Visiting Scholar at the School of Law, University of Washington, Seattle and Research fellow at the Netherlands Institute for the Law of the Sea (NILOS) / Institute of Public International Law, University of Utrecht. Prof. Nollkaemper also lectures widely at foreign universities.
He is member of the Advisory Commission on Public International Law of the Netherlands; the Standing Committee of Experts in International Refugee and Criminal Law; and counsel at Bohler, Franken Koppen Wijngaarden advocaten in Amsterdam.
Editorial positions include Editor in Chief of the Netherlands Yearbook of International Law; member of the Editorial Board of Legal Issues of Economic Integration; and the Paperbacks on International and European Law (Kluwer Law).
His practical experience includes cases before the International Court of Justice, the European Court of Human Rights, the Special Court for Sierra Leone, the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, courts of the Netherlands and consultancy for a variety of international and national organisations.
Prof. Nollkaemper has published on issues of the relationship between international and domestic law, state responsibility, international environmental law, international water law and international criminal law.
August Reinisch has been a professor of international and European law at the University of Vienna since 1998. He currently serves as Head of the Section of International Law and International Relations and as Director of the LL.M. Program in International Legal Studies. From 2004 to 2006 and as of 2010 he was/is Dean for International Relations of the Law School of the University of Vienna. His professional experience includes arbitrator and expert adviser in Austrian and foreign court litigation as well as in international, mostly investment arbitration. He has served as arbitrator in investment cases mostly under ICSID and UNCITRAL Rules, and frequently provided expert opinions in the field. Since 2001, he has been serving pro bono as arbitrator on the In Rem Restitution Panel according to the Austrian General Settlement Fund Law. He is president of the Austrian Branch of the ILA, Executive Board member of the European Society of International Law and of the German Society of International Law, and holds Master’s degrees in philosophy (1990) and in law (1988) as well as a doctorate in law (1991) from the University of Vienna and an LL.M. (1989) from NYU Law School. He is admitted to the Bars of New York and of Connecticut (since 1990). In 1994, he obtained the Diploma of the Hague Academy of International Law.
His main publications include International Organizations before National Courts (Cambridge University Press 2000), with Christoph Schreuer, Loretta Malintoppi and Anthony Sinclair, The ICSID Convention: A Commentary (Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed., 2009) and Essentials of EU Law (Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed., 2012); he has edited Standards of Investment Protection (Oxford University Press 2008) and The Privileges and Immunities of International Organizations in Domestic Courts (Oxford University Press, 2013).
PREVIOUS EDITOR IN CHIEF
Erika de Wet Co-Director of the Institute for International and Comparative Law in Africa and Professor of International Law at the University of Pretoria, and Professor of International Constitutional Law at the Amsterdam Center for International Law, University of Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Belinda Macmahon, an Australian lawyer, was with the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, Netherlands, from 2001 to 2009, where she was employed as Legal Counsel/Chief Editor. In that capacity she edited a number of books on issues of public international law, including two compilation volumes published by Oxford University Press ('Redressing Injustices Through Mass Claims Processes', 2006, and 'Multiple Party Actions in International Arbitration', 2009), six volumes of the Permanent Court of Arbitration Award Series (TMC Asser Press), and seven volumes of the PCA's Peace Palace Papers series (Kluwer Law International). She was the Registrar of the Eritrea-Ethiopia Claims Commission from 2004 until the competion of its mandate in 2009. She is qualified as a solicitor in South Australia, England and Wales, and Hong Kong SAR.
|Eyal Benvenisti||Magnus Killander||Edda Kristjansdottir|
|Tel Aviv University||University of Pretoria||University of Amsterdam|
|Claudia Martin||Riccardo Pavoni||Dinah Shelton|
|American University||University of Siena||George Washington University|
|University of Oxford|
|Anna Begemann||BjörnSchiffbauer||Beti Hohler|
|University of Oxford||University of Cologne||International Criminal Court|
|Gregor Novak||Birgit Peters||Thomas Groh|
|Yale University||University of Rostock||Berlin School of Economics and Law|
|Christian Djeffal||Gillian MacNeil|
|Higher Regional Court
EDITORIAL ADVISORY BOARD
|John Dugard||Christof Heyns||Fatsah Ouguergouz|
|University of Pretoria||University of Pretoria||African Court of Human and Peoples' Rights|
|Christoph Schreuer||Bakhtiyar Tuzmukhamedov||C.G. Weeramantry|
|University of Vienna||Diplomatic Academy||Monash University|
|Edith Brown Weiss||Rüdiger Wolfrum||Sienho Yee|
|Georgetown University||Max Planck Institute for Comparative Public Law and International Law||Wuhan University Institute of International Law|
STUDENT EDITORS | UNIVERSITY OF AMSTERDAM
|Elodie Douet||Ismini Mathioudaki||Miriam Quené||Lucie Runia|
|Natasha Smit||Dzhuliana Taushanova||Mia Tuzovic||Franziska Ziegler|
|Marit van Zandvoort||Roshan Babu Jeyakumar|
|Horace Adjolohoun||Abdullah Al Faruque||Daniele Amoroso||Helmut Philipp Aust||Davinia Aziz|
|Peter Bachmayer||J. Craig Barker||Kemal Baslar||Ed Bates||Stéphane Beaulac|
|Nita Benoliel||Camille Bergmann||Maria Teresa Bia||Kealeboga N Bojosi||Edmunds Broks|
|Catherine Brolmann||Thomas Burri||Elizabeth Cameron||Jernej Letnar Černič||Alessandro Chechi|
|Aristotle Constantinides||Sonkita Conteh||Emily Crawford||Robert J Currie||Oliver Doraisamy|
|Janine A Dumont||Saïda El Boudouhi||Olivier de Frouville||Maarten den Heijer||Paul Eden|
|Marius Emberland||Maija Faurie||Anél Ferreira-Snyman||Carlo Focarelli||Ximena Fuentes|
|Roger Gamble||Claudia Geiringer||Lena Graber||Sara B Greenberg||Thomas Groh|
|Mika Grunth||Jacques Hartmann||Matthias Hartwig||Mohamed R Hassanien||Christian Hoppe|
|Md Zakir Hossain||Devika Hovell||Kushtrim Istrefi||Massimo Iovane||Patrícia Jerónimo|
|Bing Bing Jia||Waruguru Kaguongo||Nikila Kaushik||Stephen Ke||Martijn Jurgen Keeman|
|Magnus Killander||Hugh M Kindred||Eszter Kirs||Jan Kratochvil||Shelly Kreiczer|
|Markus Lanter||Carl Lebeck||Sotirios-Ioannis Lekkas||Roemer Lemaître||CL Lim|
|Hye-Young Lim||Liang-Rong Lin||Anna-Sara Lind||Marina Litz||Tsvetanka Lozanova|
|Gillian MacNeil||Ivo Magnée||Dominique Maingot||Innocent Maja||Lesley Manthey|
|Alice Margaria||Thomas Margueritte||Sergei Marochkin||Sam Murray||Tarisai Mutangi|
|Saphina Nakulima||Salem Hikmat Nasser||Jahan Navidi||Giulio Nessi||Ilona Nieminen|
|Ragnar Nordeide||Christian Garuka Nsabimana||Opeoluwa Ogundokun||Kudret Özersay||Paolo Palchetti|
|Riccardo Pavoni||Francisco Pereira Coutinho||Priya Pillai||Ravina Pratap||Laura Precup-Pop|
|GJ Pulles||Fabián Raimondo||Mianko Ramaroson||Rohini Rangachari||Zane Ratniece|
|Markus Rau||Elena Rechapova||August Reinisch||Eva Rieter||Martin Roger|
|Cedric Ryngaert||Aziz Tuffi Saliba||Elizabeth Salmón Gárate||Birgit Schlütter||Russell Schmidt|
|Gusel Schneider||Frank Schorkopf||Dinah Shelton||Korir Sing'oei||Mateja Steinbrück Platise|
|Ralph G Steinhardt||Simonetta Stirling-Zanda||Jon Stokholm||HA Strydom||Sándor Szemesi|
|Christian J Tams||Ruth Teitelbaum||Liam Thornton||Dire Tladi||Kathryn Todryk|
|Simon Van de Walle||Harmen van der Wilt||Dries Van Eeckhoutte||Juan Santos Vara||Sten Verhoeven|
|Maarten Vidal||André von Walter||Jan Erik Wetzel||Elizabeth Wye||Anna Wyrozumska|
|Alexander Yakovlev||Keren Yalin-Mor||Andreas R Ziegler||Sara Porro||Juan Pablo Pérez-León Acevedo|